Ethan nodded. He had been studying the ground the whole way in, the way a scout does without thinking about it, marking the blind spots and the fields of fire and the places where a man could lie unseen. Now he laid it out for Nalito, plainly and without pride: how Calloway would think, what he would try first, and what he would try when the first thing failed.
He'll probe, Ethan said. "He'll send two or three men to feel the mouth of the canyon, to see if it's watched. If they come back, he'll try to draw someone out — a stolen horse left where your boys can see it, a shot fired from a ridge at dusk. He wants you angry and chasing. If that fails, he'll try the water. He'll foul the creek below the narrows, or he'll try to get above the spring. He thinks in terms of what he can take away. That's his weakness. He never thinks about what a man will do to keep what he has."
Nalito listened without interrupting, his face still and watchful, and when Ethan had finished, the war leader was silent for a long moment. Then he nodded, once, and began to give orders in a low, even voice that carried across the camp without ever being raised. Men went to the narrows with rifles and axes. Boys were sent to the high rocks with instructions to watch and not to shoot. Women began to dig a second well near the spring, in case the first was lost. It was done quickly and without argument, and Ethan saw, with a respect that surprised him, that Nalito did not need to be told how to defend a canyon. He only needed to know what kind of enemy was coming.
Ethan's own role was settled without ceremony. "You are the scout," Nalito said. "You know his face and his ways. You ride out, you watch, you come back. You do not fight alone, and you do not chase. A scout who chases is a dead scout."
It was good sense, and Ethan said so. But later, when the camp was settled and the fires were lit in their new places, Willa found him by the spring, and the argument they had been circling for days finally came out into the open.
You'll go back out tomorrow, she said. It was not a question.
Somebody has to watch the trail.
And when it's over? She stood with her arms crossed against the evening chill, and her face was set in the way it got when she had decided to say something difficult. "When Calloway is gone and the soldiers are gone and the valley is quiet again — what then, Ethan? Do you ride out the way you rode in? Is that the shape of it?"
He looked at her for a long moment, and he wanted to give her an answer, and he found that he did not have one that was honest. He had ridden into this valley a drifter, and drifters did not make promises about staying, because staying was the one thing they had proven, over and over, that they could not do.
I don't know, he said at last, and the honesty of it cost him something. "I know I won't leave while there's a fight coming. I know that much."
That's not what I asked, she said.
I know what you asked.
She was quiet for a moment, and the spring talked to itself behind her, and the smell of woodsmoke and cooking meat drifted up from the camp. "I have lived a year in a world that was not mine," she said, "and I have made it mine, day by day, by staying. You keep talking about what you owe the dead. Thomas. Mary. The baby. I understand that. But at some point, Ethan, a man has to decide what he owes the living. And the living are right here, asking him to stay."
He had no answer for that either, and she did not wait for one. She turned and walked back toward the fires, and he stood by the spring for a long time after she was gone, listening to the water and thinking about the road, and about the way it had always asked him to move, and about the strange, frightening possibility that for the first time in years, he did not want to answer it.
He did not go back to the fires at once. He walked the rim of the canyon instead, slowly, learning the ground the way a man learns a room he may have to fight in. Below, the campfires burned in their new places, small and steady, and the smell of woodsmoke rose to him on the cold air. A sentry stood motionless at the narrows, a dark shape against the darker rock. Somewhere an owl called once, and was answered by nothing. Ethan stood there a long time, with the spring water talking behind him and the whole valley spread out below, and he made himself a promise, quiet and without witnesses: he would ride out at first light, and he would watch the trail, and whatever came up it, he would be ready. It was not much of a promise. But it was the first one he had made in years that was not about the dead. And as he walked back down toward the fires, with the cold air sharp in his lungs and the canyon walls rising dark on either side, he found that the thought of staying did not frighten him the way it once had. It frightened him in a different way entirely — the way a man is frightened by something he might actually want.