Ethan thought of Klosen — quiet, hollow-eyed Klosen, whose small daughter had been coughing behind the lodges for weeks, whose wife had looked at Ethan with exhausted gratitude when he had once carried water for her. He felt a slow, complicated anger rise in him, and under it something else: pity. He pushed both down. There would be time for that later. Now he needed proof.
The letter, Ethan said. "The one you carry for Calloway. Where is it?"
Ruiz hesitated, and Ethan saw the calculation in his face — the fear of Calloway against the fear of the rifle. Then the trader stood slowly, went into the hut, and came back with a folded envelope, the paper heavy and good, sealed with wax. The handwriting on the front was a clerk's careful script: Mr. R. Calloway. Ethan broke the seal.
It was from Voss. It was all there, in language so plain it could have been a contract for cattle: the staged raid, the date, the payment in silver, the promise of more when the valley was cleared, and one line that made Ethan's hands go cold: "See that the captain's orders arrive before the blood dries. Timing is everything."
Ethan folded the letter and put it inside his own shirt, against his skin. He looked at Ruiz for a long moment. The man was sweating now, and his hands shook openly.
You're a coward, Ruiz, Ethan said, "but you're not a murderer. Not yet. If that raid happens, you are. Remember that."
What will you do with the letter? Ruiz whispered.
Show it to the people whose lives it buys, Ethan said. He lowered the rifle. "And you — you ride out of this wash tonight and you don't come back. If I see you carrying Calloway's silver again, I'll tell Dasan where to find you."
He left the trader standing in the dust, mounted his borrowed horse — a rangy roan Nalito had lent him — and rode north with the letter burning against his chest like a live coal. Behind him, the wash went quiet, and ahead of him the mountains stood blue and indifferent, and for the first time in days Ethan felt something he had almost forgotten how to feel: not hope, exactly, but the shape of it. He had proof. He had a name for the leak, and a letter that tied a land company's money to a massacre that had not happened yet. He rode hard, and the wind came down off the Dragoons smelling of pine and coming snow, and he thought of Willa's face, and of the camp waiting in the hidden canyon.
The canyon received him the way a held breath receives air. Ethan rode in at dusk on the third day, the roan lathered and blowing, and found the camp gathered around the central fire as if the whole band had been waiting in one place for him to come back or not come back at all. Dasan sat with his blanket around his shoulders. Nalito stood with his arms crossed, his face unreadable. Willa was at the edge of the firelight, and when she saw him her hand went to her mouth, and then dropped, and she did not run to him, which told him more than running would have.
He dismounted, and Goshi took the roan without a word. Ethan walked to the fire and stood before the chief, and took the letter from inside his shirt, and laid it on the blanket between them.
I found the leak, he said. "And I found the plan."
Dasan read the letter slowly. He read it twice. The fire popped and hissed, and no one spoke. Then the chief looked up, and his old eyes were steady and terrible.
Calloway, he said. "Voss. And silver, paid to one of ours."
Ethan nodded. "Ruiz carries the letters. He told me the man who met him was young, with a sick little girl. He took silver to buy medicine in Red Wash, and gave news in return. Where the camp was. When the scouts rode."
A murmur ran around the fire like wind through dry grass. Ethan watched the faces. He saw Klosen sitting apart, near the edge of the light, with his wife beside him, and he saw the man's shoulders go rigid, and then slump, as if a rope inside him had been cut. Klosen stood. His face was gray. His hands hung at his sides, empty.
It was me, he said, and his voice was low and steady, and carried across the whole camp. "I did it."
Nalito was on his feet in an instant, his knife half out of its sheath, and two warriors moved with him. Dasan raised one hand, and they stopped, though Nalito's jaw worked like a man chewing something bitter.
Speak, Dasan said.
Klosen came forward into the firelight. He was twenty-eight, and he looked forty. "My daughter," he said. "The fever. She coughs until she cannot breathe, and Tzeh's medicine holds it back but does not cure it. The trader said the medicine in Red Wash would cure her. I had nothing. No silver, no horse to sell. Calloway's man came to me at the arroyo and offered me silver, and asked only for news. I told myself it was small news. Where we camped. When the scouts went out. I told myself no one would be hurt." His voice broke. "Then the raid came, exactly where I said the scouts would not be. I knew then what I had done. I have known every day since."