His wife made a small sound and covered her face. From the lodge behind them came the thin, terrible cough of the little girl, and the whole camp heard it, and the anger around the fire changed its shape, the way a river changes around a stone.
Nalito spoke, and his voice was hard. "He sold us. Men could have died. The canyon itself —"
Men did not die, Ethan said, and every head turned toward him. "Because Willa stood by me, and because the camp fought well. And because this man told me the truth of it the moment I had the letter in my hand." He looked at Dasan. "Chief, I have a word to say before the council judges him."
Dasan nodded slowly. "Say it, Ethan Vale."
I know what it is to trade something precious for someone you love, Ethan said. He felt the old wound open in him — Mary, and the baby, and the winter of 1873, and all the things he had not been able to buy or bargain or beg his way out of. "I know what it is to sit beside a sick child and have nothing in your hands. Klosen did a wrong thing. He did it for the most human reason there is. If we kill him, his daughter dies too — of the fever, or of grief, and we will have answered a betrayal with a cruelty that makes us smaller. Let him live. Let him be exiled from the band, and let his daughter stay, and be cared for. That is justice that does not poison the well."
Silence. The fire burned down to coals. Ethan could hear the creek, and the coughing from the lodge, and his own heart, loud in his chest.
Dasan looked at Nalito. Nalito looked at Klosen for a long time — at the man's shaking hands, at his wife, at the lodge where the child coughed — and then he sheathed his knife with a slow, deliberate motion, as if sheathing it cost him something real.
Exile, Nalito said. "He leaves at dawn, alone, and never returns to Red Rock. If he is seen again, the judgment is death. That is my word."
Dasan nodded. "It is the council's word. Klosen, you are no longer of this band. Your daughter remains. Old Mother Tzeh will take her into her lodge and care for her as her own. Go and say goodbye to her, and then go."
Klosen went to his knees. He pressed his forehead to the ground before Dasan, and then before Ethan, and his shoulders shook, and he said nothing at all, because there was nothing left to say. His wife helped him to his feet, and they walked together into the dark toward the lodge, and the camp sat in silence around the dying fire.
Before the fire burned down, Ethan walked to the lodge where the child lay. He did not go inside. He stood in the doorway, where the lamplight fell across the dirt, and watched Tzeh spoon warm broth between the little girl's lips, a few drops at a time, patient as rain wearing down stone. The girl was small — five, maybe six — with her father's dark hair and a cough that shook her whole thin frame each time it took her. Klosen knelt beside her pallet, and his wife knelt on the other side, and Klosen spoke to his daughter in a low voice, telling her he had to go away for a while, telling her the old mother would care for her, telling her to be brave and to drink her broth. The girl reached up with one small hand and touched his cheek, and said something Ethan could not hear, and Klosen bowed his head, and his shoulders shook, and he stayed that way, bent over his child, until his wife put a hand on his back and whispered that it was time. Ethan turned away before the goodbye was finished. He had seen enough. He had seen a man lose everything he loved in order to save the one thing he loved most, and he had argued that the man should live with it, and standing there in the dark he wondered whether mercy was a gift or only a slower kind of sentence. He thought of Mary, and of the winter of 1873, and of how he would have traded anything — anything at all — for one more day, and he knew that he had done the only thing he could do, and that it would have to be enough.
Later, when the council had broken and the people had gone to their lodges, Old Mother Tzeh came and stood beside Ethan at the edge of the firelight. She was small and bent and sharp-tongued, and she smelled of smoke and herbs, and she looked at him with eyes that missed nothing.
You argued for a man who betrayed us, she said.
I argued for his daughter, Ethan said.
Same thing, tonight, she said. Then, grudgingly: "It was well argued. The People will remember it."
She went into the lodge to sit with the sick child, and Ethan stood alone by the fire, and felt the camp's trust settle around him like a blanket he had not expected to be given. He had ridden out alone under suspicion, and he had come back with proof, and with mercy, and something in the air of the canyon had changed. He looked toward Willa's lodge, and saw the faint glow of her fire through the hide, and thought of the letter in his pocket and the battle that was coming, and for the first time since he had ridden into this valley, he did not feel like a stranger waiting to be sent away.