Until now.
"Where did you get that?" he asked.
"I found it outside my cabin door at daybreak."
Noah looked up.
"Your cabin?"
"Yes."
"When?"
"This morning."
Silas released a dry, rasping laugh.
"Convenient place for a horse thief to leave evidence, wouldn't you say, Bennett?"
Hannah's fingers curled around the charm.
"You know I didn't steal her, Silas."
"I know you owe three hundred dollars in taxes," he replied, taking a slow step forward. "And I know the county sheriff has instructions to attach property when the ledger remains unpaid."
"That isn't the same as stealing a horse."
"No. But desperation has a remarkable way of changing a person's character."
Hannah's cheeks reddened.
Noah noticed that she did not lower her eyes.
Silas looked past her shoulder, addressing Noah as though Hannah were no longer present.
"She heard you were unmarried, Bennett. Living out here on eighty acres without a woman to keep your mind sharp. Perhaps she thought a lonely rancher might be easier to fool with a pretty face and a brass trinket."
The insult hung between them.
Hannah went very still.
Noah's expression hardened.
"Careful, Crowe."
Silas raised one eyebrow.
"Did I say something offensive?"
"You said enough."
"Then perhaps you'd better listen before you decide whose side you're taking."
Noah ignored him.
He looked at Hannah.
"Why did you bring this to me?"
"Because it's yours."
"That much I know."
"I thought you might recognize it."
"I do."
"Then you know I didn't make it."
Noah turned the brass charm over in his fingers.
The three notches were unmistakable.
He had filed them himself.
"Why would someone leave this outside your cabin?"
"I was hoping you could help me answer that."
"You think the person who took Willow is connected to you?"
"I think someone wants me to believe that."
Silas shifted his weight.
"Or perhaps she simply wishes to distract you from more pressing matters."
Noah looked at him.
"What matters?"
Silas smiled.
"The Reed land."
Hannah's expression changed.
Noah saw it immediately.
There was fear beneath her anger, something deeper than the ordinary anxiety of a person struggling with unpaid bills.
He had seen that expression before, usually on men who had received bad news from a doctor or heard the first gunshot during a nighttime raid.
"What does a missing mare have to do with you, Hannah?" he asked.
She swallowed.
"My brother disappeared three nights ago."
The valley seemed to grow quieter.
A breeze moved through the dry grass, carrying the faint smell of river water and distant cattle.
Noah's eyebrows drew together.
"What's his name?"
"Eli."
"How old?"
"Twenty-two."
"Where did you see him last?"
"At our cabin on Tuesday evening."
"Was he going somewhere?"
"He had gone into town. He came home late, after dark."
"Was he alone?"
"I believe so."
"You believe?"
"He said he was."
Noah studied her face.
Hannah seemed to be struggling with the words, deciding how much she could trust a man she had barely spoken to in years.
Then something in her expression gave way.
"He was excited," she continued. "More excited than I've seen him since Father died. He said he'd been searching through the old surveyor ledgers in the courthouse basement."
Silas sighed.
It was a calculated sound, designed to communicate boredom.
Hannah continued.
"He said he'd found something recorded in eighteen forty-nine. Something that could save our land from the tax sale."
Noah glanced toward Silas.
The older man's expression had not changed, but his fingers had stopped moving against the polished handle of his walking stick.
"And what exactly did he find?" Noah asked.
"I don't know. He wouldn't tell me everything. He said he wanted to make copies first. He told me that if the record was what he believed it to be, we wouldn't owe Crowe anything."
Silas pulled a silver pocket watch from his waistcoat.
He opened its cover and studied the time.
"The Reed place is drowning in debt, Bennett. The girl has been listening to a foolish young man fill her head with stories instead of accepting what every sensible person in this valley already knows."
"And what's that?" Noah asked.
Silas snapped the watch shut.
"That the land will belong to me by winter."
His words were delivered without anger or excitement.
They sounded like a simple statement of fact.
"The tax deed comes up for auction on the first of November," he continued. "I hold the primary mortgage notes from the bank in town. The county has already been notified."
Hannah's jaw tightened.
"My father paid for that land with four years of clearing oak stumps and three thousand dollars in gold coin."
"Your father has been dead six years, child."
The word child seemed to sting her more than anything else.
"Dead men don't pay county assessments," Silas continued. "And living ones who cannot hold a plow don't keep seventy acres of bottomland."
"My brother can work."
"Your brother is missing."
"Then perhaps you should help us find him."
Silas's eyes narrowed.
For a brief moment, the pleasant expression disappeared from his face.
Then it returned.
"I offered you a fair arrangement last month, Hannah. You could have remained in the house as a tenant. I even offered to employ Eli as a hand on my upper range."