It was a small sound, almost rusty from disuse, but it changed the atmosphere of the kitchen.
"You're very accustomed to giving orders."
"Only when people insist on doing foolish things."
"Then I imagine you spend most of your time giving orders."
"More than I'd like."
He handed her the lantern.
"Wait here. I'll saddle a horse."
They left the Bennett property just after sunset.
Noah rode his bay gelding, Copper, while Hannah sat behind him, holding the saddle horn with one hand and the lantern with the other.
The evening air had cooled.
Across the valley, the first stars appeared above the dark outline of the hills. The road followed the creek for nearly two miles before turning east toward the Reed property.
Noah kept Copper at a slow walk.
Hannah said little.
He could feel the tension in her body whenever the horse passed beneath overhanging branches.
After a while, he spoke.
"Did you recognize the handwriting on the note?"
She turned slightly.
"What note?"
"The message Eli left. Did he leave anything for you?"
Hannah hesitated.
"Not exactly."
"What does that mean?"
"He wrote something on the back of an old envelope. I found it on the kitchen table after he disappeared."
Noah glanced over his shoulder.
"What did it say?"
She swallowed.
"Only four words."
"What were they?"
"Don't trust the survey."
Noah slowed Copper.
"That's all?"
"Yes."
"Did you keep it?"
"I did."
"Where is it now?"
"In my pocket."
Noah felt a cold uneasiness settle in his stomach.
The survey was supposed to be the key to saving the Reed property.
But Eli had warned her not to trust it.
That meant either the document was false, or someone had altered it.
Or the danger was not in the survey itself.
It was in the person who had found it.
Noah looked toward the dark fields.
"Tomorrow morning, we're going to the courthouse."
Hannah stiffened.
"We?"
"If Eli found something in the old records, we need to see it."
"You don't have to involve yourself."
"I know."
"Silas won't like it."
"I know that too."
"Then why?"
Noah considered the question.
He thought about his mare returning exhausted and injured.
He thought about the cut rope.
He thought about a young man disappearing after discovering something in the county records.
And he thought about the fear in Hannah's eyes whenever Silas Crowe came near her.
"Because someone has decided that my horse is part of this," he said. "And I don't appreciate strangers making decisions about my property."
Hannah was quiet for a moment.
Then she said, "That's the only reason?"
Noah looked straight ahead.
"No."
He did not explain further.
The road curved toward the Reed cabin.
A dim light burned in one of the windows.
Hannah leaned forward.
"That's strange."
"What?"
"I put out the lamp before I left this morning."
Noah tightened the reins.
Copper slowed.
The cabin stood beneath two old cottonwood trees, its weathered boards nearly black in the fading light. A small barn sat behind it, and a narrow fence enclosed the kitchen garden.
Everything looked ordinary.
Too ordinary.
Noah dismounted first.
"Stay here."
Hannah climbed down before he could stop her.
"Noah—"
He held up his hand.
"Quiet."
They listened.
The wind moved through the cottonwoods.
Somewhere beyond the barn, a loose gate creaked.
Then Noah heard something else.
A faint metallic sound.
Like a chain striking wood.
He reached for the revolver at his belt.
"Hannah, go behind me."
She obeyed.
Together, they approached the cabin.
The front door stood slightly open.
Noah pushed it with the barrel of his revolver.
The hinges groaned.
Inside, the kitchen lamp burned on the table.
Beside it lay a folded piece of paper.
Noah stepped into the room.
The floorboards creaked beneath his boots.
He glanced toward the bedroom, then the rear door.
Nothing moved.
Hannah entered behind him.
"Someone's been here."
Noah examined the table.
The paper was folded twice.
There was no envelope.
No name.
He opened it.
Three words had been written in dark ink.
Bring back the horse.
Hannah covered her mouth.
Noah read the message again.
Then he looked toward the open doorway.
Outside, something moved in the darkness beyond the barn.
He drew his revolver.
"Stay inside."
A branch snapped.
Noah stepped onto the porch.
The night seemed suddenly enormous.
"Who's there?"
No answer.
He moved down the steps.
The grass rustled near the fence.
Then a horse snorted.
Noah turned toward the sound.
A black gelding stood beneath the cottonwoods.
Its reins were tied to the fence.
And hanging from the saddle horn was a small brass crescent moon.
The same charm.
Only this one was new.
Noah felt the blood drain from his face.
Someone had made another.
And whoever it was had come close enough to the cabin to leave it while Hannah was away.
He raised his revolver toward the darkness.
"Show yourself."
A low laugh drifted from somewhere beyond the trees.
Then a man's voice spoke.
"Tell Bennett to stop digging."
The sound came from the western field.
Noah fired once into the air.
The black gelding reared.
By the time Noah reached the fence, the darkness had swallowed whoever had spoken.