Every road might conceal a watcher.
Every friendly face might belong to a man who had sold his loyalty to Silas Crowe.
And somewhere in the valley, Eli Reed was either hiding from the men who wanted him silenced—or being held by them.
Noah had no intention of letting the mystery remain buried.
Not after finding his father's name in the ledger.
Not after discovering that the truth had been purchased, hidden, and protected by violence.
And certainly not after watching Hannah risk everything to find her brother.
The Schoolhouse at the Crossing
The old schoolhouse stood where the valley narrowed, just beyond a bend in the creek.
It had been built from rough-hewn timber nearly forty years earlier, when the settlement consisted of little more than a handful of farms, a trading post, and a church. Children had once walked miles through the fields to sit at its narrow desks, learning their letters beneath a roof that leaked whenever the rain came hard.
Now the windows were broken, the door hung crookedly, and weeds had swallowed the path leading to its entrance.
Noah approached from the north, keeping Copper at a walk.
Hannah rode behind him on Ranger, one hand gripping the saddlebag containing the original survey. She had barely spoken since they left the Reed property.
The sheriff's visit had changed something.
Until that morning, she had believed the law might still offer some protection. Now she understood that the man responsible for enforcing it had helped steal her family's land.
She looked toward the schoolhouse.
"Why would Eli come here?"
Noah studied the building.
"Your father's map marked this place."
"But the second ledger could be anywhere."
"Perhaps. But your father knew the valley. He wouldn't have marked a place without a reason."
They dismounted near the creek.
Noah tied the horses beneath a cottonwood and examined the ground.
There were tracks.
Some belonged to deer, others to cattle that had crossed the creek during the previous week. But beneath them, Noah found a pair of bootprints.
Fresh.
He crouched.
"Someone's been here."
Hannah stepped closer.
"How recently?"
"Yesterday, perhaps. Maybe this morning."
He followed the prints toward the schoolhouse.
The tracks were uneven. One boot had left a deeper impression than the other, as though the person had been limping.
Hannah looked at him.
"Could it be Eli?"
"Possibly."
She hurried forward.
Noah caught her arm.
"Wait."
He pointed toward the ground near the doorway.
A cigarette butt lay in the dust.
It was still relatively clean, with a small amount of tobacco remaining inside.
Noah picked it up.
"Someone was watching the entrance."
"Could it have been one of Crowe's men?"
"Could be."
He placed the cigarette butt in his pocket.
Then he drew his revolver and pushed the door open.
The hinges groaned.
Inside, the schoolhouse smelled of damp wood and old paper. Dust covered the desks. A broken slate lay near the teacher's platform, and a faded map of the United States hung crookedly on the wall.
Hannah moved toward the front of the room.
"I remember my father bringing us here."
Noah glanced at her.
"When?"
"After the school closed. Eli wanted to see the old books. He was fascinated by anything that had writing in it."
She stepped toward a desk near the window.
"He used to sit here."
A faint smile appeared.
"He carved his initials into the underside."
Noah crouched and examined the desk.
The wood was cracked, but the letters remained.
E.R.
Beneath them was a second marking.
A small crescent moon.
Noah touched it.
"Your brother made this?"
"Yes. He used to carve that shape into everything."
Noah thought of Willow's bridle charm.
"Did he ever explain why?"
"He said it reminded him of the moon over the creek. When we were children, we used to sit outside and watch it rise."
She looked at the carving.
"He always said the moon made the world look like it was hiding something."
Noah straightened.
"Perhaps he was right."
They searched the desks, the cupboards, and the small storage room behind the teacher's platform.
They found old lesson books, broken chalk, and a collection of children's drawings.
But no ledger.
Hannah was examining a shelf when Noah noticed a loose floorboard near the back wall.
He knelt and lifted it.
Beneath the board was a narrow cavity.
Inside lay a folded piece of cloth.
Noah pulled it free.
It was a strip of faded blue fabric.
Hannah stared.
"That's from my dress."
He looked at her.
"Are you sure?"
She touched the cloth.
"Yes. It came from the dress I wore the day Eli disappeared."
Noah examined it.
A small dark stain marked one edge.
Blood.
Hannah's face tightened.
"He was here."
"Maybe."
She looked toward the door.
"Why would he leave this?"
Noah unfolded the cloth.
Something small fell onto the floor.
A brass button.
Hannah picked it up.
It was old and worn, with a small crescent engraved in the center.
She turned it over.
On the back, someone had scratched a number.
17.
Noah examined it.
"Does that mean anything?"
Hannah shook her head.
"Not to me."
He looked toward the old map on the wall.
"Seventeen could be a page number. A parcel number. A marker."