But now the truth was beginning to threaten that trust.
She stepped inside.
Noah stood beside the table, looking at the original survey.
He did not turn when she entered.
"Do you believe him?" she asked.
Noah was silent.
Then he said, "I believe he knows something."
"About your father?"
"Yes."
"Do you believe your father killed mine?"
Noah finally turned.
"No."
Hannah searched his face.
"You're certain?"
He looked down at the survey.
"No."
It was the first time he had admitted that uncertainty aloud.
Hannah moved closer.
"Then what do we do?"
Noah folded the map.
"We find the letter."
"And the second ledger?"
"We already have the original survey. The second ledger may contain the proof we need."
"And Eli?"
Noah looked at her.
"We find him first."
Hannah nodded.
Outside, the wind moved through the cedar branches.
Somewhere in the darkness, a horse whinnied.
Noah went still.
He crossed to the window and looked through a narrow gap in the boards.
A faint light flickered between the trees.
A lantern.
Then another.
Men were moving through the forest.
And they were coming toward the ravine.
Noah turned toward Hannah.
"Put out the lamp."
She extinguished it immediately.
Whitcomb reached for his walking stick.
"How many?"
Noah watched the lights.
"At least three."
He lifted his revolver.
Then, from somewhere beyond the trees, a voice called out.
"Mr. Bennett!"
Noah recognized it.
Garrett Pike.
"Come outside. We only want the ledger."
Noah looked at the saddlebag.
Hannah stood beside him, her face pale but steady.
Pike called again.
"You've got something that belongs to Silas Crowe."
Noah moved toward the rear wall.
There was a narrow opening behind the cabin, leading down into the ravine.
He pointed toward it.
"Hannah, take the survey and go."
She shook her head.
"I'm not leaving."
"That's not a request."
"And I'm not asking permission."
Noah stared at her.
Then he understood.
She was not refusing because she doubted him.
She was refusing because she had finally found someone who would stand beside her, and she would not abandon him when danger arrived.
He nodded once.
"Stay close."
Outside, Pike laughed.
"Last chance, Bennett."
Noah raised his revolver.
Then a shot struck the cabin wall.
Wood splintered beside his head.
Hannah ducked.
Whitcomb fell to one knee.
And the first bullet of the night tore through the window.
The Ravine of Shadows
The bullet tore through the cabin window and buried itself in the wall above the table.
For one breathless instant, nobody moved.
Then Garrett Pike shouted from outside.
"Last warning, Bennett!"
Noah dropped behind the table, his revolver raised. Hannah crouched beside him, clutching the saddlebag containing the original survey. Whitcomb had fallen near the stove, one hand pressed against his chest.
"Are you hit?" Noah whispered.
The old surveyor shook his head.
"Just stumbled."
Another shot struck the door.
The hinges rattled.
Noah looked toward the narrow opening behind the cabin. Beyond it, the ground dropped sharply into the ravine, where the creek ran between steep banks covered with brush.
"There's a trail down there," Whitcomb whispered. "It leads to the northern slope."
"How far?"
"Half a mile. Then the ravine opens into a pine clearing."
Noah nodded.
"Hannah, take the papers."
She tightened her grip on the saddlebag.
"What about you?"
"I'll follow."
She looked at the revolver in his hand.
"You cannot hold them off alone."
"I don't intend to."
A heavy impact struck the door.
The wood cracked.
Pike's voice came again.
"Don't make me burn the place down!"
Noah looked toward the stove.
A small fire still glowed beneath the iron grate. If Pike set the cabin alight, the smoke would fill the room before they could escape.
"Go," Noah said.
Hannah crawled toward the rear opening.
Whitcomb followed, moving awkwardly with his walking stick.
Noah waited until both had disappeared.
Then he fired once through the front wall, aiming high.
A man outside shouted.
Noah used the moment to reach the rear opening.
He slipped through just as another shot shattered the remaining window.
The ground dropped beneath his boots.
He slid down the narrow bank, catching branches to slow himself. Loose stones rolled into the creek below.
Hannah waited near the water.
Whitcomb stood beside her, breathing heavily.
Noah landed beside them.
"Move."
They followed the creek north.
Behind them, the cabin door burst open.
Pike's voice echoed through the trees.
"They're going down the ravine!"
Noah urged Hannah forward.
The trail was steep and slippery. Roots twisted across the earth, and low branches caught at their clothing. The creek provided cover, but it also slowed their progress.
They had not gone fifty yards when a bullet struck the water.
Hannah ducked.
Noah turned and fired toward the ridge.
A figure disappeared behind a cedar.
"Keep moving!"
They reached a narrow bend where the creek passed beneath a fallen tree. Noah helped Hannah across, then turned to Whitcomb.
The old man was struggling.
His walking stick had caught between two rocks.
Noah grabbed his arm.
"Come on."
Whitcomb pulled free.
Then a shot cracked above them.
He stumbled.
Noah caught him before he fell.
"You're hit?"
Whitcomb looked down.
Blood spread across the shoulder of his coat.