"Why?"
"Because the men who have been watching you are waiting for you to do exactly that."
Noah glanced toward the trees.
The old surveyor was right.
The schoolhouse stood in the open, and the road was visible from both sides of the creek.
They had been exposed for too long.
"Where can we go?" Noah asked.
Whitcomb looked toward the north.
"There is a cabin beyond the timberline. I have kept it supplied for years. No one knows about it."
Hannah shook her head.
"We're not going anywhere until you tell us where Eli is."
"I don't know."
"Then why should we trust you?"
Whitcomb looked at her.
"Because if I wanted you dead, I would have brought Pike with me."
Noah considered that.
It was not a convincing argument.
But it was not meaningless either.
He glanced toward the horses.
"Move."
Whitcomb nodded.
They crossed the creek and approached the animals.
Noah mounted Copper.
Hannah climbed onto Ranger.
Whitcomb remained on foot.
"Where's your horse?" Noah asked.
"I don't have one."
Noah looked at the old man's walking stick.
"Then you'll ride with me."
Whitcomb hesitated.
"I can walk."
"Not through the timber."
The old man climbed behind Noah.
They rode north.
For the first mile, Noah said nothing.
He was still trying to reconcile the two versions of his father.
The man who had taught him to mend fences and honor a handshake.
The man who had apparently helped alter a property survey.
The man who had ridden to Thomas Reed's house on the night of his death.
He remembered his father's final words.
Whatever happens, son, don't let another man's fear become your burden.
At the time, Noah had thought he was talking about the ranch.
Now the sentence seemed to carry a different meaning.
Hannah rode close beside him.
She looked over once.
He knew what she wanted to say.
But there was nothing she could offer that would make the truth easier to bear.
They continued toward the timberline.
Behind them, the old schoolhouse stood empty beneath the morning sun.
And on the far side of the creek, concealed among the trees, Garrett Pike lowered his field glasses.
He watched the riders disappear.
Then he turned toward his horse.
"Well," he muttered, "now we've got them."
He mounted and rode south.
Silas Crowe was waiting.
And this time, Pike intended to bring him more than a report.
He intended to bring him the name of the man who had finally found the second ledger.
A Cabin Beyond the Timberline
The timberline began where the valley's open grasslands gave way to a steep rise of pine and cedar.
The trail narrowed as they climbed. Loose stones shifted beneath the horses' hooves, and branches scraped against their coats. The sun had passed its highest point, but the air beneath the trees remained cool.
Noah rode slowly.
Whitcomb sat behind him, one hand gripping the saddle and the other resting on his walking stick.
Hannah followed close enough to hear them if they spoke.
For nearly an hour, the old surveyor said nothing.
Noah finally broke the silence.
"You knew my father well?"
"Well enough."
"How?"
"We worked together."
"On the survey?"
"Before that. Your father helped build the first bridge across the creek. Thomas Reed supplied the timber. I was a young surveyor then."
Noah glanced back.
"Why did they trust you?"
Whitcomb gave a tired laugh.
"Because I was foolish enough to believe that a man with a government seal could not be bought."
"And now?"
"Now I know better."
Noah looked ahead.
"Tell me about the agreement."
Whitcomb was silent for a moment.
"Silas Crowe wanted the eastern crossing. He approached your father first because Daniel owned the adjoining ranch and had influence with the other landowners."
"My father refused?"
"At first."
"At first?"
Whitcomb shifted in the saddle.
"Daniel had debts. Your grandfather left the ranch in poor condition, and your father spent years trying to restore it. There were unpaid loans, a failing cattle herd, and a mortgage that seemed to grow every year."
Noah said nothing.
He knew about the old debts. His father had never hidden the difficulty of those years, but he had also never spoken of any arrangement with Crowe.
Whitcomb continued.
"Crowe offered to pay the debts in exchange for Daniel's help persuading the county to move the boundary."
"And my father agreed?"
"He agreed to consider it."
"That's not an answer."
"No. It isn't."
Whitcomb looked toward the trail.
"Daniel signed an agreement. But before the survey was changed, he tried to withdraw."
Noah's jaw tightened.
"Why?"
"Because he discovered that Crowe intended to take more than the crossing. The altered survey would also strip Thomas Reed of the land his family had farmed for thirty years."
"And then?"
"Daniel went to Thomas. He told him what he had done."
Noah felt a knot tighten in his chest.
"Why would he do that?"
"Because he knew the agreement was wrong. He wanted to undo it."
"Did Thomas forgive him?"
"I believe so."
"Then why was Thomas killed?"
Whitcomb looked down at his hands.
"Because Crowe had already paid Mallory and Pike. Once the survey was altered, too many people had something to lose by correcting it."