Willow lifted her head.
For one brief moment, recognition returned to her eyes.
Then her front legs buckled.
Noah reached her before she struck the ground, catching the reins and guiding her downward into the grass.
"Easy. Easy now."
The mare shuddered.
Hannah stood frozen.
"That's her," she whispered.
Noah looked up.
"Yes."
"She's alive."
"She is."
Hannah pressed one hand against her mouth.
Something in her expression changed.
She had come to the Bennett place expecting suspicion, perhaps even rejection. Instead, she had found a missing horse, a possible connection to her brother, and a man who had placed himself between her and the most powerful landowner in the county.
But Willow's condition frightened her.
The mare looked as though she had traveled through hell to reach the ranch.
Noah examined her legs, then carefully ran his hands along her flanks.
There were cuts beneath the dried mud.
Not accidental scratches.
Several narrow, deliberate marks.
His fingers stopped at the left shoulder.
Beneath the mud was a deep wound.
Someone had struck her with a sharp object.
"Who did this to you?" he whispered.
Willow lowered her head against his shoulder.
Noah felt her trembling.
Hannah approached cautiously.
"Can I help?"
"Get me a bucket of water from the trough."
She hurried away.
Noah loosened the girth strap and removed the damaged bridle. When he lifted the saddle blanket, he noticed something caught beneath its rear edge.
A small strip of dark fabric.
He pulled it free.
It was torn from a coat sleeve.
Black wool.
Noah stared at it.
Silas Crowe's coat had been black wool.
He looked toward the county road.
The older man was gone.
But something told Noah that the trouble had only just arrived.
Willow nearly collapsed a second time before Hannah returned with the water.
Noah had managed to guide the mare beneath the shade of the old cottonwood near the corral. Its branches spread wide over the pasture, providing the only substantial shelter on that side of the property. The ground beneath it was soft with fallen leaves and darkened by years of shade.
He had removed the bridle and saddle, laid them carefully beside the fence, and was examining the wound on Willow's shoulder when Hannah came hurrying across the yard.
She carried a wooden bucket in both hands.
Water sloshed over its rim and darkened the front of her dress.
"Here."
"Set it down."
Noah took the bucket and placed it near the mare's head.
Willow sniffed the water but did not drink.
"She needs time," he said.
"Is she badly hurt?"
"Badly enough."
He dipped a clean cloth into the bucket and began wiping the dried mud from her shoulder.
The mare flinched.
Hannah crouched beside him.
"That looks deep."
"Someone cut her."
"With a knife?"
"Possibly."
"Why would anyone do that?"
Noah did not answer immediately.
He was looking at the wound.
The cut was narrow and angled, beginning near the shoulder blade and running downward toward the front of the leg. It had been made by a sharp instrument, but the edges were irregular, suggesting Willow had been moving when the blade struck her.
There were other marks too.
A swollen place beneath the saddle line.
Two parallel abrasions along her right flank.
A rope burn around the base of her neck.
Noah's mouth tightened.
"Someone tied her too tightly."
Hannah looked away.
"She must have been frightened."
"Yes."
"Will she recover?"
"If the wound hasn't become infected, she should."
"And if it has?"
Noah met her eyes.
"Then we'll deal with that when we know."
He spoke gently, but Hannah could hear the worry beneath his words.
Willow finally lowered her muzzle toward the water.
She drank slowly.
Noah watched her carefully, making certain she did not swallow too quickly after what appeared to have been a long period without water.
"That's it," he murmured. "Take your time."
Hannah rested a hand against the mare's neck.
The animal leaned slightly toward her.
"You know her well," Hannah said.
"Better than most people."
"How long have you owned her?"
"Three years."
"She's beautiful."
"She's troublesome."
A faint smile touched Hannah's mouth.
"What kind of trouble?"
"She once broke through a fence because she decided the grass on the other side looked better."
"Perhaps it did."
"She had a whole pasture to herself."
"Then perhaps she wanted company."
Noah glanced at her.
For the first time, something resembling amusement appeared in her eyes.
It vanished almost immediately.
"Do you think she was trying to get back here?" Hannah asked.
"I think she knew where she belonged."
The words seemed to settle between them.
Hannah looked down at the mare.
For a moment, she appeared to be thinking about something much farther away than the pasture.
Noah returned to cleaning the wound.
He had treated injured animals since he was a boy. His father had taught him how to recognize swelling, fever, and infection, and his mother had insisted that an animal in pain deserved patience rather than force.
He remembered sitting beside a dying calf one winter night while his father held a lantern over them.
A living creature, his father had said, could endure a great deal if someone gave it a reason to keep fighting.