He turned the page.
Beneath the list was a short paragraph.
The original survey was altered before the county filing. Thomas Reed knew the boundary was wrong. He was paid to remain silent.
Hannah stepped backward.
"No."
Her voice was barely audible.
"No, that's not true."
Noah closed the notebook.
"Hannah—"
"My father would never have taken money from Silas Crowe."
"We don't know when this was written."
"He died six years ago."
"I know."
"He spent his whole life trying to protect that land."
Noah looked down at the page.
There was a date in the corner.
Six years earlier.
The same year Thomas Reed had died.
Hannah shook her head.
"Someone is lying."
Before Noah could answer, a noise came from above.
A heavy footstep.
Then another.
Noah extinguished the lantern.
The cellar fell into darkness.
He raised his revolver.
A man's voice drifted down the stairs.
"Well, well."
Noah recognized it immediately.
Garrett Pike.
"Looks like we found our little treasure hunters."
Hannah's hand closed around Noah's sleeve.
He whispered.
"Stay behind me."
The footsteps continued down the stairs.
Then Pike laughed.
"Mr. Bennett. You should have stayed home."
Noah aimed toward the stairwell.
"Come any closer and you'll regret it."
Pike stopped.
"That's a mighty brave thing to say in the dark."
A match struck.
For one brief moment, the cellar filled with orange light.
Garrett Pike stood halfway down the stairs, holding a revolver.
Behind him stood two other men.
Noah recognized one of them as a ranch hand from Crowe's upper range.
The other carried a shotgun.
Pike smiled.
"Now, why don't you hand over that notebook?"
Noah's grip tightened.
"Come take it."
Pike's smile disappeared.
"Gladly."
The first shot shattered the lantern.
Darkness exploded around them.
Noah heard Hannah cry out.
He fired twice toward the stairs.
A man shouted.
Then something heavy crashed against the wooden table.
Noah grabbed Hannah's hand.
"Move!"
They stumbled toward the rear wall, where a narrow opening led into an old drainage passage.
He had found it years earlier while exploring the mill as a boy.
He pushed Hannah through.
Behind them, Pike shouted.
"Don't let them get away!"
Noah followed.
The passage was narrow and wet, barely wide enough for a man to crawl through. Hannah moved ahead, holding the notebook against her chest.
The sound of gunfire echoed behind them.
A bullet struck the stone wall.
Dust filled the air.
They reached the far opening and emerged into a ditch beside the creek.
Noah pulled Hannah upright.
"Run!"
They raced toward the horses.
A shotgun blast tore through the branches above them.
Ranger reared violently.
Hannah grabbed the reins.
Noah reached Copper and swung into the saddle.
"Get on!"
She climbed behind him.
Copper surged forward as Noah drove his heels into the gelding's sides.
They galloped through the timber.
Behind them, Pike's voice rose above the gunfire.
"You're not leaving this valley alive, Bennett!"
Noah did not look back.
He knew the man had meant every word.
And in his shirt pocket, the folded notebook pressed against his ribs like a piece of evidence that might get them both killed.
The Truth Beneath the Dust
They did not stop until they reached the northern ridge.
Copper's breathing came hard beneath the saddle, and Hannah's arms were locked tightly around Noah's waist.
The trees thinned as the ground rose toward a rocky overlook. From there, the old mill was visible through the morning haze.
Noah pulled the reins.
Copper slowed.
For several seconds, the only sound was the gelding's labored breathing.
Hannah loosened her grip.
"Are you hurt?"
Noah looked down.
There was a shallow cut along his right forearm. Blood had begun soaking through his shirt.
"Nothing serious."
She touched his sleeve.
"You're bleeding."
"I've noticed."
"Let me see."
"First, we need to make sure nobody followed us."
He turned Copper toward a narrow trail leading behind the ridge.
They descended into a sheltered hollow where a spring fed a small pool beneath the rocks.
Noah dismounted.
Hannah followed.
He examined the surrounding ground, listening for movement.
Nothing.
Only the soft trickle of water.
"Help me with the saddle," he said.
She looked at him.
"Why?"
"We'll stay here for a few minutes. Copper needs water."
Hannah led the horse toward the spring.
Noah removed his hat and wiped his forehead.
The attack at the mill had confirmed something he had feared.
The notebook mattered.
Whatever Eli had discovered, Silas Crowe was willing to use armed men to keep it hidden.
Noah reached inside his shirt and removed the leather notebook.
Its edges were damp, and a corner had been torn during their escape.
He opened it carefully.
The list of names was still there.
Hannah approached.
"Can I see?"
He handed it to her.
She turned several pages, reading silently.
Her expression grew increasingly troubled.
"There's something else."
Noah leaned closer.
She pointed to a line near the bottom of the final page.
The second ledger was placed where the water once stopped.
Noah frowned.
"What does that mean?"
"I don't know."
"Could it refer to the original creek bed?"
"Perhaps."
She examined the map again.
"The old schoolhouse was built near the first river crossing."
Noah looked toward her.