"What are the comments saying?" Dot asked, in a voice she barely recognized.
Mouse scrolled, and read her a selection, and the selection was a river: Look at him drop the weapon. He didn't even think. My dad died choking in a restaurant in 2019 and nobody knew what to do, I'm crying. This is what a man is. Lock him up anyway. Hero. Criminal. Both. The word both appeared, Mouse reported, several thousand times, as if the internet had been waiting years for a video it could argue about with its whole chest, and had been handed, instead, a video that refused to be argued into a single shape.
By Monday night the clip was on the national news, cropped, captioned, slowed down at the critical pull by a morning-show producer who added music Dot considered a criminal act in its own right. By Tuesday a cable host had called Troy Bickel "the Heimlich robber," and the name, which Troy would hate with a completeness he could never quite explain to his lawyer, was on T-shirts being sold by a man in another state. The diner phone began to ring with a persistence that Jenna compared to a smoke alarm. Reporters wanted Dot. Reporters wanted the judge, who was not yet discharged and was dictating refusals to a hospital spokesman with the enthusiasm of a man who has found his weekend's real entertainment. Reporters wanted, most of all, the one person who could not be produced: a thirty-one-year-old roofer in the county jail, in an orange jumpsuit, whose bond hearing was Thursday, and who had asked his court-appointed lawyer, in their first meeting, only two questions — whether the old man was all right, and whether being on television meant the other inmates had seen it. The answer to the first was yes. The answer to the second was also yes, and Troy Bickel had put his head down on the interview table, in the posture of a man receiving weather, and said, "Then I guess I don't get to decide what I am anymore," which his lawyer, a tired and decent man named Frank Osei, thought was the saddest and most accurate thing a client had ever said to him, and he had been doing the work for nineteen years.
The diner, in those first days, became an unwilling embassy. Television trucks discovered that Main Street had exactly one place to park a satellite uplink and that Dot Kessler considered the space in front of her door to be a fire lane, a position she defended with a garden hose's moral authority and, once, with Sheriff Cole's actual authority, summoned by landline and delivered in person, with a citation book opened to no particular page — a piece of theater the sheriff and the nurse had plainly rehearsed in some previous life. The trucks retreated to the fairgrounds. From there the crews made their expeditions: to the courthouse, to ask the clerk questions the clerk had answered in a press release; to the fire hall, where Erin's brother-in-law, who had inherited the chief's job along with everything else, told them Caleb's widow was not a story and closed the door with a courtesy that fooled no one; to the school, where the principal protected his third-grade teacher with the dunk-tank zeal the town knew well.
Jenna they caught once, on the diner's back step, with a bag of trash in her hand, which the footage of her — twenty seconds, looped for a day on two networks — showed her carrying like a professional while saying, "I pressed a button. The button's the story. Buttons work if somebody installs them, tests them, and believes the person who says press it. Interview the button." This made her, to her horror, a folk hero of the process-minded, and produced a wave of mail she answered exactly none of, and an invitation to speak at a first responders' conference which she declined twice and accepted once, in the spring, on the conditions that it be about alarms and not about her, and that she could bring Dot as her guest. Priya Nair, tracked down in Morgantown by a producer, said the memorable thing — "Everyone asks who the hero was. In an ICU we'd say: the room was. Rooms are or they aren't" — and thereby, in the newspapers, founded a small school of thought that Grace Holloway quoted at riders' meetings for a year.