"A jury will. The video is the first exhibit. Both of you are in it, Mr. Fenn. One of you is holding a gun on a nurse. One of you is not." She let that sit. Alvarez was twenty-nine and owed her own future to a scholarship and a stubborn streak wider than Dale's, and she had watched the footage eleven times with a legal pad, and she had reached the professional conclusion that her client's best asset was the one thing he kept insisting was a lie about him: the gun had been unloaded, and Dale, if he could survive cross-examination about why he hadn't known that — and God, that was going to be a cross-examination — could argue he had never intended a shooting, only a taking. "Your cousin," she said, changing ground, "has been charged separately about the truck. He's talking, Dale. I need you to understand what that means and stop writing him letters."
What Dale understood, in the way of Dale, was that the architecture of blame was being rebuilt without him. It was the story of his life as he told it: the room empties, the credit flows, the consequences settle like sediment on Dale Fenn. That Troy had carried an old man's weight and Dale had carried a gun; that the difference between them had been visible, in real time, to forty-seven witnesses and a camera; that no conspiracy was required to explain the difference in how the world had received them — none of this penetrated, because to let it penetrate would have been to accept that Saturday night had not happened to Dale Fenn but had been authored, in part, by him. He fired Alvarez on a Tuesday and was assigned another lawyer on Thursday, a slow, careful man named Baird who opened their first meeting by saying, "Mr. Fenn, I am going to tell you a lot of things you don't like. Men in your position who fire the people telling them those things tend to meet the maximum sentence socially. Let us not." Dale kept him. It was, though Dale would never have framed it so, the first decision he made all autumn that was in his own interest, and it happened because Baird, alone among the adults of Dale's recent life, addressed him as a man whose choices were still worth the effort of disputing.
Lisa Bickel's part in that autumn was conducted largely by telephone, from a double-wide outside Elkins with a baby who had decided that sleep was a rumor and a daughter — Troy's daughter, Mara, seven, in her custody by a family arrangement the courts had blessed in the spring — who had begun asking the questions that dismantle households. Why is Uncle Troy on the news. He isn't your uncle, baby. Why does the lady on the news say his name like that. Mara had seen the clip at a friend's house, because seven-year-olds live in a country with no borders, and she had watched her father, whom she knew mostly from supervised visits and a gap-toothed photograph economy running the other direction, lift an old man out of a booth on television, and her question, delivered to Lisa at the sink in the tone of a auditor, was the one no adult had yet managed: "Was he being good or being bad?" Lisa, who had a decade's practice at answering Mara's questions with the exact truth at the exact size it could be carried, said: "Both, baby. In the same five minutes. That's why it's on the news. If he'd only been one, nobody'd have filmed it." Mara considered this with the ferocity of a judge. "When's he coming to my recital?" "Not this one," Lisa said. "He's in trouble for the bad part, for a while. I'm not going to lie to you about the while." "Will you tell him I played?" "I'll write it in the letter. Every note."
Lisa wrote the letters the way she did everything, in the twenty-minute increments the baby allowed, and she kept them — this was her discipline, arrived at through one furious consultation with Ruth — entirely free of the two things Troy's situation attracted from everyone else: verdict and absolution. She sent news. She sent Mara's spellings and the baby's statistics and their mother's furnace reports, and once, in November, after the Slade news, a single sentence of her own buried in the middle like a stone in a field: I don't know who you are right now, Troy, but I know who wrote me back in October, and I'm keeping him. The letter Troy sent in answer took him nine drafts, which the prison's mail procedures turned into a small geology of effort arriving over two weeks, and it contained, Lisa would tell Ruth at Christmas, the first sentence her brother had written to her in fifteen years that did not contain an apology, an excuse, or a request: It said, Mara's trumpet is a war crime and I think about it every morning at count, and it makes the morning. Lisa read that sentence to Mara verbatim, war crime and all, over the objections of no one, and Mara, delighted, practiced with renewed and terrible purpose.