THE NIGHT THEY PICKED THE WRONG DINER

Chapter 36

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Dot stood in her own doorway and cried for the second time that autumn, which equaled her total for the previous five years, and then made Grace Holloway come in out of the rain and eat a piece of pie standing up in a kitchen with no floor to speak of while the two of them planned the work like a campaign. The work took nine days. Berger's tile — warm gray this time, practical, with a border Jenna chose, a deep green she defended as "the color of the creek when it's behaving" — went down in three. The electricians rewired the kitchen circuits on new, raised runs. Silas Grant rebuilt the low shelving a foot higher, flood height, with a brass marker screwed at the waterline inside the pantry door and the date painted on it by Mouse, because, Silas said, buildings should keep their records where the next fool can read them. The health inspector returned on the ninth day, walked the building twice, ate a piece of pie at the counter in violation of no regulation he could think of, and signed the reopening with a flourish.

Dot reopened on December the twenty-third with the same menu, a new floor, and a line out the door. The Christmas trade did not care about the national news, which had moved on, exactly as Grace had predicted, to fresher wonders. It cared that the diner was back. Somebody — the investigation into this was even more half-hearted than the last — had hung a wreath over booth four. And on Christmas Eve, at closing, Dot found an envelope in the register, unsigned, containing cash in an amount she counted three times because she did not trust the first two: the remainder, the exact remainder, of a paramedic school deposit. Jenna got it for Christmas in the pass-through with Marcus pretending not to witness, and cried, and accused three people by name, and was not believed by anyone, least of all herself.

Chapter 36: Dale's Trial

Dale Fenn was tried first, in February, because his case was the simpler of the two and because Baird, his lawyer, had concluded after the plea negotiations failed — Dale had rejected an offer of nine years with the bewildered fury of a man refusing a lifeboat's color — that a jury, shown the whole of it, might give them what negotiation hadn't: a distinction between the robbery as planned and the robbery as it had detonated, between an unloaded gun and an intended execution. It was not a foolish bet. It was merely a losing one, and the difference, as Baird told his wife afterward, is the whole of trial law.

The courtroom was full on the first day in a way the county had not seen since a murder trial in the nineties. The video played on a screen that made it small and grainy and therefore, somehow, more terrible — forty-seven people at supper, a door, a shout, and then the long minutes like a held breath, and Dale's own voice, cracking on move, filling a courtroom that had heard everything. Dot testified on the second day, and said under cross-examination the thing she had said in every interview she'd refused to give: "He was frightened the whole time. I want the jury to know that because it's true, not because it helps him. A frightened man with a gun is not safer than a calm one. That's rather the point of my giving up nursing to feed people." Baird, at his table, wrote something down and did not smile, because it was the best and worst sentence his case would produce.

Jenna testified about the truck, the note, the alarm. Three seconds, she said, and held her hand up the way she had at the pass, and the prosecutor let the silence teach the jury what three seconds can buy: a sheriff staged six minutes away, a room warned, a child moved from the glass. Grace testified about geography. Sheriff Cole testified about an empty magazine, and held it up in its evidence bag, and Dana Whitaker, in closing, built her argument out of the three facts no one had disputed: a plan, a gun presented as death itself, and forty-seven people who would check their doors, some of them, for the rest of their lives. "Mr. Fenn asks you to grade his intentions," she said. "The law asks you to grade his acts. He brought the terror. That the terror did not become a killing is owed to a nurse, a waitress, a roomful of strangers — and to the decency of the man he brought with him. It is not owed to Dale Fenn, and he may not spend it."

News in the same category

THE NIGHT THEY PICKED THE WRONG DINER

45 Part