Jenna grinned and put the envelope away and tied her apron tighter, and then the door bell went and the afternoon crowd came in all at once, festival families shaking rain off like dogs, kids wired on kettle corn, a quartet of quilters from the senior center who ordered pie in four different flavors and then traded plates in a rotation so complex it needed a referee. Jenna worked the room the way she did everything, fast and accurately and with her whole attention, remembering that the man in booth two took his tea unsweet, that the baby in the high chair needed crackers now and not in five minutes, that old Mr. Sato, who was hard of hearing and prouder than Lucifer, must never, ever be shouted at but shown the menu with the day's special already circled.
It was during that rush, refilling coffee at the window booth, that she first noticed the truck. It sat across the street in the feed store lot, a gray pickup with a dented tailgate, engine running, two men inside not getting out. Nothing about it was remarkable except the license plate, which was caked with mud in a way that looked deliberate, and the fact that the passenger kept looking at the diner the way you look at a building you are memorizing. Jenna had grown up the daughter of a man who worked highways; she knew what a vehicle waiting looked like, and what it didn't.
She told herself she was tired and festival-brained. She poured the coffee. But she took her phone out in the pass-through and typed a note to herself with the time and the description, because the rescue squad had taught her that too: write it down when you see it, not when you're sure. By the time she looked up again the truck was gone, leaving two faint tracks in the wet gravel, and the diner was loud and warm and full, and Jenna shook the moment off and went back to work, because there were forty people between her and her envelope and every one of them wanted pie.
Chapter 5: The Man Who Said No
Dale Fenn was thirty-six years old and he had been angry in an organized way since he was twelve, when his father left for a shift at the mine and came home three days later with his things in a garbage bag and a decision nobody explained. Dale had done two stretches in county jail, one for breaking into cars and one for breaking into a pharmacy, and he would tell anyone who asked, and several who didn't, that the system had never given him a fair shake. What he would not tell anyone was that he had been offered fair shakes, plural, and had recognized each one mainly as an insult to his intelligence.
He met Troy Bickel in the county jail in August, in the way men meet there, which is to say in line, over food neither of them wanted, with the whole architecture of the place designed to make friendship unlikely and alliance inevitable. Troy owed money. Dale, who had a cousin who had a friend who parked cars at the fairgrounds in another county, had what he called information. The harvest festival in Cedar Hollow, Dale explained, took in cash all weekend, thousands of it, and the festival committee, being small-town and trusting, kept the receipts in the safe of the diner across from the courthouse until the bank opened Monday. He had heard this from a man who had heard it from a woman who worked a funnel cake stand. It was, in every particular that mattered, wrong. The festival committee banked its receipts nightly by sheriff's escort, and the diner safe held, at most, a weekend float and Dot Kessler's late husband's watch. But Dale Fenn had the confidence of a man who had never once checked a fact that flattered him, and Troy Bickel had a debt, and a debt can make a bad fact look like a door.
"We go in Saturday night, late, near closing," Dale said, in the motel room off the interstate where they had been planning for two days among pizza boxes and a television neither of them watched. "Masks, gloves, in and out. Old lady runs the place. She'll hand it over. Nobody's a hero over a cash box, Troy."
"She's not just an old lady," Troy said. "People know her. She was a nurse."
"Then she'll be sensible. Nurses are sensible."
Troy was thirty-one, younger than Dale and softer in every way that jail had not yet planed off him, and he kept turning his phone over in his hands, where a text from a number he had saved under no name sat unanswered. He said, "What if there's people?"
"Festival Saturday, nine o'clock, it's raining fit to flood. There'll be nobody." Dale said it with total certainty, and Troy, who wanted desperately to believe that the worst night of his life could also be the last one, nodded the way a man nods at weather he cannot change. Outside the motel window the rain kept falling on the highway, and the neon sign buzzed and stuttered, and Dale spread a hand-drawn map of Cedar Hollow's Main Street on the bed and began, once again, to explain how easy it was going to be.