The jury was out for five hours. Dale Fenn was convicted on every count that mattered — armed robbery as charged, the gun's emptiness going, as the law coldly provides, to sentencing rather than to guilt — and he received, in April, twelve years, with the judge (Whitfield's successor, who read his predecessor's letter into the record though it addressed the other defendant, because, she said, the court would keep the whole record whole) observing that the sentence reflected both the crime's gravity and the single mercy Dale could actually claim: that on the evidence, he had carried an unloaded weapon, and that when the moment came to set it down, he had set it down. Dale heard all this standing, and did not cry this time, and looked, as he was led out, not at the cameras but at the empty chair where his cousin had been expected and had not come.
Chapter 37: Troy's Reckoning
Troy Bickel pleaded guilty in March, in a hearing that took fourteen minutes, which Frank Osei had told him to expect and which he had nonetheless not believed: two years of consequences, a nationally televised crime, a state-level investigation into a gambling operation — all of it, in the end, compressed into a judge reading counts and a man in a suit his mother had bought saying yes, Your Honor, in the right places, in a voice that did not shake, because Troy had decided that whatever else the plea was, it would not be a performance.
The plea agreement, hammered out over the winter between Osei and Dana Whitaker in an office whose radiator knocked like a man asking to be let in, reflected the whole arithmetic of the case at once: the robbery, admitted in full; the stolen truck, admitted; the cooperation against Vernon Slade, credited and specified; the rescue, entered into the record not as a defense — Osei had been clear-eyed from the first meeting that the law would not let it be one — but as grounds, at sentencing, for the court's discretion. Whitaker, who was not a sentimental prosecutor, had insisted on one clause over her own staff's objections and would defend it later in two bar association panels and one angry editorial: Troy Bickel's guilty plea would be taken in open court with the victim impact letters read first, all thirty-one that wished to be, before allocution. "If his rescue is going to be in the record," she said, "so is the door-checking. He doesn't get a curated file. Neither do we."
So Troy Bickel stood in April, in a full courtroom, and listened for two hours to what he had done, read aloud by the people he had done it to. Erin Reese read hers herself. She did not look at him until the last paragraph, and then she did, steadily, like a woman identifying something for the record, and said, "I want him to know that I check on my daughter in the night now. And I want him to know that last month she stopped checking the doors herself, because children heal in the direction of whoever holds them. I'm trying to say both things are his to carry. Not just the second one." Tom Berger's letter was read by his wife because Tom had wept at the rehearsal of it in their kitchen and had sworn he would not do it in a courtroom. Mouse's three sentences took twenty seconds and emptied the room's composure entirely.
Then Whitfield's letter was read — by the judge's own former clerk, at Whitfield's written request, the judge himself sitting in the gallery's second row in a suit, with his cane, having declined a place of honor because, he said, he was a witness in this matter and witnesses sit where they're put. It separated the debt from the deed in language so clean that the court reporter, afterward, asked for a copy for her own files. It did not ask for mercy. It observed that the defendant had, unbidden and at cost, restored to the writer the whole remainder of his life, and that the court, in weighing a sentence, weighs a life, and that the defendant's life must therefore include, at full size and without discount in either direction, both the eleventh of October's plan and its four minutes and eleven seconds.
When it was Troy's turn he stood, and said the thing he had written and rewritten for six weeks in a cell, most versions of which Osei had gently shredded. "I went there to rob those people. There's no other start to it. I told myself it was about a debt, but plenty of people owe money and don't put on a mask, and I keep thinking about how I almost didn't — follow him in, I mean. I stood in the parking