"What did you do in response?"
"I told the employee to update the file."
"Did you reopen the complaint?"
"No. At the time, I believed the case had been properly reviewed."
"On what evidence?"
"The officer's statement and the information available to us."
"Did you review the recordings?"
Haines hesitated.
"I may have."
"Can you identify any notes you made after reviewing them?"
"No."
"Can you identify any document showing that you watched the footage before closing the case?"
Haines placed the email on the table.
"Not without reviewing the archive."
Shaw folded her hands.
"Lieutenant, the department's records show that the closure decision was made before all the requested evidence was available. The file also lacks documentation that the recordings were reviewed. Why should we conclude that the investigation was complete?"
Haines's expression became defensive.
"Because we handle hundreds of complaints every year. We have to make decisions based on the information available. If we reopened every case whenever someone submitted another document, we would never finish anything."
"No one is asking you to reopen every case. We're asking why this one was closed before the requested evidence arrived."
"I made a judgment based on what I knew at the time."
"Then help us establish what you knew."
Haines looked toward the recorder.
For the first time, he seemed to understand that the interview was not a routine review of paperwork.
He had expected to explain an administrative decision and move on.
Instead, he was being asked to reconstruct the reasoning behind that decision, identify the evidence he had examined, and account for the records that were missing.
"I'll need to speak with my representative before answering further questions," he said.
"That's your right," Shaw replied.
She stopped the recording.
Haines gathered his papers and left the room.
Shaw remained seated for several moments, reviewing her notes.
She did not know whether Haines had deliberately ignored evidence or had simply become accustomed to closing cases quickly.
But she knew the distinction mattered.
A careless investigation could deprive a person of justice.
A deliberate cover-up could undermine the entire department.
And both possibilities required a thorough examination.
Two days later, Daniel Price agreed to provide a formal statement.
He arrived at the independent review office carrying a small notebook and a folder containing the documents Rachel had collected. He wore a clean work shirt and dark trousers, and he looked as though he had spent the previous night preparing himself for a difficult conversation.
Bennett met him in the reception area.
"Mr. Price?"
"Yes."
"I'm Marcus Bennett."
Daniel shook his hand.
"Thank you for seeing me."
"I'm glad you came."
They entered a quiet interview room where Evelyn Shaw was waiting.
Before the recording began, Shaw explained the process, described how the statement would be used, and told Daniel that he could request a break whenever he needed one.
Daniel listened carefully.
"I want to make something clear before we start," he said.
"Go ahead."
"I'm not here because I want revenge on Mercer. I don't want his family to suffer. I don't want people sending threats to his house. I don't even know what should happen to him."
He looked at the recorder.
"I just want the truth about what happened to me."
Bennett nodded.
"That's a reasonable request."
Daniel took a breath.
"Then I'll tell you everything I remember."
He described leaving the warehouse after his shift, driving along the road, and stopping at a gas station to check a tire. He explained that he had noticed the patrol car behind him but had not thought much about it until the lights came on.
He remembered lowering the window and handing over his identification.
He remembered asking why he had been stopped.
He remembered the officer's tone changing.
At one point, Daniel stopped speaking and pressed his hands together.
"There's something I haven't told anyone before."
Shaw waited.
"When the officer pulled me out of the car, I was scared. I knew I hadn't done anything wrong, but I also knew that arguing could make things worse. So I tried to stay calm."
He looked down.
"I remember thinking about my daughter. I had promised to take her to school the next morning because my sister was working early. I kept telling myself that if I stayed polite, the officer would realize there was a mistake and let me go."
His voice became quieter.
"But he kept getting angrier."
Bennett said nothing.
"At one point, I asked him to loosen his grip because my shoulder hurt. He told me to stop resisting. I wasn't resisting. I was trying not to fall."
Daniel rubbed his wrist.