"I know that, too."
"Then why are we treating every old complaint as though it might be evidence of a conspiracy?"
"Because some complaints may have been mishandled, and we have a responsibility to find out why."
Reeves shook his head.
"You are allowing Bennett to turn one roadside incident into a departmental crisis."
Whitaker's expression changed.
"No. Mercer turned a roadside incident into a serious matter when he arrested someone without establishing a lawful basis. We made it worse by discovering that earlier complaints may not have received adequate review. Bennett did not create those facts. He brought them to our attention."
Reeves stared at him.
"What happens if this review damages the careers of good officers?"
"Then we will examine the evidence and make decisions based on what it establishes."
"And what happens if the public loses faith in us?"
Whitaker rose from his chair.
"Then we will have to earn that faith back."
The room fell silent.
Reeves collected himself.
"I will cooperate with the review."
"I expect you to."
After Reeves left, Whitaker remained standing.
He had no certainty that the investigation would vindicate every allegation. He knew that the department would face criticism regardless of what the final report said. Some residents would believe the officers had been treated unfairly. Others would argue that the department had failed to protect the public.
But he could no longer allow fear of criticism to determine what questions were asked.
He returned to his desk and wrote a short instruction to the internal affairs division.
All unresolved concerns about complaint handling, evidence preservation, and supervisory review were to be documented and submitted to the independent team.
Then he added one final sentence.
No employee was to be penalized merely for raising a good-faith concern about departmental practice.
He signed the order.
For the first time in months, he felt that he had made a decision for the right reason rather than the convenient one.
Daniel Price struggled with the decision to return to the police headquarters for a second interview.
He had given his statement, provided the records, and answered every question the investigators asked. He wanted to believe that his part was finished.
But the review team had discovered a discrepancy in the original arrest report that required clarification.
The report stated that Daniel had refused to identify himself before the search. Yet the dispatch record showed that Mercer had already transmitted Daniel's name and driver's license number before the arrest.
The difference mattered because the report used the alleged refusal as part of its justification for the detention.
Daniel arrived at the interview office after finishing an early shift at the warehouse.
Rachel came with him, waiting in the lobby while he met with Shaw and Bennett.
Shaw explained the discrepancy.
Daniel listened, then shook his head.
"I gave him my license almost immediately."
"Do you remember whether he asked for it more than once?"
"He asked me to hand it over. I did. He looked at it and walked away."
"Did he tell you that you were being investigated for a specific offense?"
"No."
"Did he explain why he wanted you out of the car?"
"He said he wanted me to get out. I asked whether I was being detained, and he got angry."
Bennett leaned forward.
"Mr. Price, I want you to understand that you don't have to guess at anything. If you don't remember a detail, say so. We are not asking you to make your account fit the report. We're asking what you actually remember."
Daniel nodded.
"All right."
He described the encounter again, carefully distinguishing between what he remembered clearly and what he could only reconstruct from the documents.
When the interview ended, he stepped into the corridor and found Rachel waiting.
"How did it go?" she asked.
"I think it went all right."
"Are you sure?"
"No," he admitted. "But I told them what I remembered."
Rachel took his arm.
"That's all you can do."
They walked toward the exit.
Near the front doors, Daniel stopped beside a large display honoring the department's fallen officers. Rows of names were engraved into dark stone. A small vase of flowers stood beneath the display.
He looked at the names for a moment.
"I don't want people to think I hate every police officer," he said.
Rachel followed his gaze.
"Nobody who knows you would think that."
"I know officers who helped our neighborhood after the storm. I know a detective who found my daughter's missing backpack when she left it on the bus. There are people who do this job because they want to help."
"Then you can believe that and still expect them to do their jobs properly."