After handing over her folder, she remained near the reception desk, watching the employees move through the lobby. Officers passed carrying coffee cups and stacks of paperwork. A detective laughed at something his colleague said. Somewhere behind a closed door, a telephone rang repeatedly before someone finally answered it.
Everything looked ordinary.
That was what troubled her.
For almost a year, she had imagined that the place where her brother's life had fallen apart would look different from every other government building. She had imagined angry people shouting in the corridors, exhausted families demanding answers, and officials scrambling to explain themselves.
Instead, the building was calm, clean, and completely indifferent to what had happened to Daniel.
She wondered how many people had walked through those doors carrying the same kind of folder, believing that this time their voices would matter.
"Ms. Price?"
She turned.
A woman in a dark blue suit stood beside the reception desk. She appeared to be in her forties and carried a tablet beneath one arm.
"My name is Evelyn Shaw. I'm with the independent review team. Mr. Bennett asked me to speak with you."
Rachel tightened her grip on the strap of her handbag.
"Is this going to take long?"
"We can take as much time as you need."
"I have to be at work in two hours."
"Then we'll start with the most important information, and we can arrange another meeting if necessary."
Rachel studied the woman, looking for the familiar signs of impatience she had encountered during her earlier attempts to file a complaint.
She found none.
"All right."
Shaw led her into a small interview room. There was a table, four chairs, a box of tissues, and a recorder placed beside a stack of blank forms. The room had no windows, and the fluorescent lights hummed softly overhead.
Rachel sat down.
Before Shaw began, she asked whether Rachel wanted water.
The simple question nearly brought tears to Rachel's eyes.
For months, every interaction with the department had felt like a test she was destined to fail. She had been asked whether her brother had been drinking, whether he had raised his voice, whether he had made any sudden movements, and whether he had perhaps misunderstood what the officer was saying.
Nobody had asked whether she was comfortable.
Nobody had asked whether she needed a moment.
She accepted the water and took a slow breath.
"Let's start with the night Daniel was arrested," Shaw said. "Tell me what you remember, beginning wherever it makes sense to you."
Rachel opened the folder.
Inside were copies of court documents, photographs of Daniel's damaged car, letters from his former employer, and several handwritten notes she had made after the arrest.
"My brother worked at a distribution warehouse on the west side of the city," she began. "He worked nights because the pay was a little better. He was trying to save enough money to buy a house for his daughter."
She paused.
"Daniel is a good father. He isn't perfect, but he's never been the kind of person who looks for trouble. He fixes things around the house, takes his daughter to school when he can, and works overtime whenever someone offers it."
Shaw listened without interrupting.
"That night, he was coming home from work. He called me because his car was making a strange noise. He said he was going to stop at a gas station and check the tires. About twenty minutes later, I received a call from an unknown number."
Rachel looked down at the papers.
"It was Daniel. He told me he had been arrested."
"What did he say happened?"
"He said the officer claimed he was driving suspiciously. Daniel asked what he had done wrong. The officer told him to stop asking questions."
Rachel rubbed her thumb against the edge of the folder.
"Daniel told me he gave the officer his license and registration. He said the officer took them, walked around the car, and came back demanding that he get out. When Daniel asked whether he was being detained, the officer became angry."
"Did your brother identify the officer?"
"Yes. Daniel remembered the name on his uniform. Officer Mercer."
Shaw made a note.
"What happened after the arrest?"
"They searched the car. They didn't find anything illegal. Daniel told me they kept asking him where he was coming from and who he had been with. He answered every question he could. Then they charged him with resisting an officer."
"Did the report indicate that he physically resisted?"
Rachel shook her head.
"That's the part I couldn't understand. The report said he pulled away and refused to put his hands behind his back. Daniel said the officer twisted his arm before he even had a chance to turn around."