Shaw described the initial examination of complaints involving Mercer, the discrepancies in the Price case, and the evidence suggesting that some investigations had been closed without complete documentation.
She explained the limitations of the available recordings and the need to establish who had accessed certain files.
She also described the broader supervisory issues identified during interviews with former and current employees.
"We have not concluded that every complaint reviewed was valid," she said. "We have not concluded that every recording failure involved deliberate misconduct. And we have not determined that every supervisor who participated in a closure decision acted improperly."
She paused.
"What we have established is that the department's existing process did not consistently ensure that relevant evidence was reviewed before complaints were closed. In some cases, the documentation is insufficient to demonstrate that required steps were completed."
A murmur moved through the audience.
Shaw continued.
"We have also identified concerns about standardized report language, inconsistent property records, and the absence of a systematic audit of recording failures. These issues require further investigation and corrective action."
Dr. Foster leaned toward her microphone.
"Can you tell us whether the department had a policy requiring recordings to be reviewed during complaint investigations?"
"Yes. The policy required investigators to consider available recordings when relevant to the allegation."
"Was that policy followed in the Price case?"
"The records do not establish that it was followed adequately. The file contains evidence that the recording was accessed, but we have not yet established who reviewed it or whether the relevant portions were examined before the complaint was closed."
"Is that a policy violation?"
"It may be, depending on the findings of the ongoing investigation and the responsibilities assigned to the individuals involved."
Dr. Foster nodded.
"Thank you."
She turned toward Chief Whitaker.
"Chief, what steps has the department taken in response?"
Whitaker rose.
"We have preserved relevant records, reassigned responsibility for several reviews, and begun an audit of previously closed complaints. We are also examining the procedures governing body-camera footage, evidence inventories, and supervisory approvals."
"Have any employees been disciplined?"
"Officer Mercer remains on administrative suspension. Other personnel decisions are being considered as the evidence develops."
"Has the department acknowledged that some complaints may have been mishandled?"
Whitaker looked toward the audience.
"Yes. The preliminary findings indicate that some complaint reviews were incomplete. We need to understand why that happened and ensure that it does not happen again."
A reporter raised her hand.
"Chief, do you believe your department failed Daniel Price?"
Whitaker paused.
He could have offered a carefully worded statement about the investigation being ongoing. He could have said that the department took all complaints seriously and that individual cases required individual review.
Those statements would have been safe.
They would also have avoided the question.
"I believe the records raise serious questions about how Mr. Price's complaint was handled," he said. "I cannot yet tell you who is responsible for every failure. But I can tell you that the department should have ensured that all relevant evidence was reviewed before the complaint was closed."
Daniel looked down at his hands.
For months, he had wondered whether anyone in authority would ever admit that something had gone wrong.
The chief's words did not restore his lost job or erase the arrest.
But they marked the first time the department had publicly acknowledged that his complaint deserved more than a dismissal letter.
After the presentations, Dr. Foster invited public comments.
Rachel approached the microphone first.
She unfolded a piece of paper, looked at it, and then set it aside.
"My name is Rachel Price. I'm here because my brother was arrested by Officer Mercer last year."
The room became quiet.
"I have heard a lot about procedures, evidence, policy, and administrative review. I understand that those things matter. I understand that you cannot simply decide someone is guilty because another person makes an accusation."
She looked toward the commission.
"But I want you to understand something, too. While the department was deciding whether my brother's complaint deserved attention, he was trying to explain to his daughter why he had disappeared from home for two nights. He was trying to find another job. He was trying to pay legal bills. He was trying to convince himself that he hadn't done something wrong simply because a police officer said he had."
Her voice trembled, but she continued.
"We were told the complaint was closed. We were told there wasn't enough evidence. We were told that the department had reviewed the matter."
She took a breath.
"Now we are learning that the evidence may not have been reviewed properly at all."
Rachel looked directly at Whitaker.