He had written it after Haines told him that Price's complaint was attracting attention from an outside advocacy group.
At the time, Reeves had meant to prevent speculation from spreading before the facts were clear.
But he could see how the sentence might look to someone reading it without the conversation that preceded it.
He could also see how easily the sentence could be interpreted as an instruction to limit scrutiny.
“I have some old messages,” he said.
“Related to Price?”
“Possibly.”
“Have you preserved them?”
“Yes.”
“Then you need to disclose them through the appropriate process.”
Reeves rubbed his hands together.
“What if the wording is misunderstood?”
“Then you explain the context. But if you conceal the message because you're worried about how it will look, you create a different problem.”
He looked toward the door.
“I was trying to prevent the department from being damaged by an incomplete story.”
“Were you also trying to prevent anyone from finding out that the story might be incomplete?”
Reeves did not answer.
Miriam gathered the papers.
“I'm not asking you to confess to something you didn't do. I'm asking you to stop treating the possibility of embarrassment as a reason to withhold relevant information.”
When Reeves returned to his office, he shut the door and opened the cabinet where he kept old administrative records.
The messages were still there, preserved in a printed file he had assembled during a previous internal review. He read them in order, paying attention to the dates.
The first concerned the complaint.
The second concerned the report.
The third referred to the outside advocacy group.
The fourth was his own message: Keep this contained until we know what we have.
He sat for a long time with the page in front of him.
Then he called Miriam.
“I have records I need to provide,” he said.
“Good. Do you know what they contain?”
“Yes.”
“Do you believe they change your earlier answers?”
Reeves closed his eyes.
“They change the context.”
“Then we'll make sure the context is included.”
He sent the records to the legal adviser for preservation and disclosure. He did not delete any messages or attempt to rewrite the file. Yet the decision offered little comfort. He knew that once the review team read the communications, the questions would become more difficult.
At the same time, Lieutenant Haines was beginning to lose control of his own account.
He had spent the previous evening reviewing the small black notebook he had taken from his locker. He had considered destroying it, but the thought made him feel sick. The notes were not a complete record of events, but they were the closest thing he had to a private chronology.
He had written them because he distrusted the official recordkeeping system.
Now he feared what his own records might reveal.
The entry about Reeves was especially troubling. Haines remembered the conversation clearly. The deputy chief had called him into his office after learning that Price's complaint had been referred for outside review.
Reeves had asked whether the report was complete.
Haines had said that the report had been submitted but that questions remained about the video.
Reeves had asked what kind of questions.
Haines had explained that the camera angle was limited and that Mercer remembered hearing a command before the movement described in the report.
Reeves had been silent for several seconds.
Then he had said, “We need to make sure the department doesn't get dragged through a public dispute before we know what we have.”
Haines had interpreted the sentence as a warning to keep the matter from spreading.
He had also understood it as permission to control who received information about the case.
Later, when the access review was proposed, he had not objected.
He had told himself the change was routine.
He had told himself that restricting access would prevent rumors.
He had told himself that the investigators would eventually obtain whatever evidence they needed.
But when the review team discovered the canceled export request, those explanations began to sound like a series of convenient stories told to avoid a single uncomfortable question.
What had he intended when he initiated the export?
He remembered wanting to create a working copy of the footage. He remembered believing that the original file was difficult to review because the system's playback interface kept freezing. He remembered starting the process, then canceling it when a call came in.
But he also remembered that he had not included the canceled request in his later explanation of how the video had been handled.
He had considered it irrelevant.