Rachel stood behind him, reading over his shoulder.
“They found more records,” she said.
“Yes.”
“Does that mean they know what happened?”
“Not yet.”
She sat across from him.
“You sound like Naomi.”
“Maybe she's rubbing off on me.”
Rachel gave a small, reluctant smile.
For the first time in weeks, Daniel felt a little of the tension leave his shoulders. The investigation was still uncertain, and the public attention made him uncomfortable. But the case was no longer trapped in a cycle of denial and silence.
Someone had found records.
Someone had acknowledged questions.
Someone had decided that those questions deserved answers.
It was not justice. Not yet.
But it was movement.
That evening, Naomi called with an update.
“The review team has asked us to provide a supplementary chronology,” she said. “They want the dates of every communication you remember receiving after the arrest, including the anonymous call.”
Daniel took out his notebook.
“I can do that.”
“Be as specific as you can, but don't fill in gaps. If you aren't sure whether something happened on Tuesday or Wednesday, say that.”
“I will.”
“And Daniel?”
“Yes?”
“Don't discuss the investigation with anyone who contacts you unexpectedly. If a person claims to have information, ask them to contact our office or the review team directly.”
He remembered the unknown caller.
“Do you think someone might try to stop me from cooperating?”
“I don't know. We have no evidence that anyone has threatened you in connection with the investigation. But given the circumstances, it's sensible to document any unusual contact.”
After the call, Daniel wrote down everything he remembered about the anonymous caller. He described the voice, the timing, the words, and the fact that the number had appeared as blocked. He noted where he had been sitting and whether anyone else had been nearby.
The details were imperfect.
He made no attempt to improve them.
When he finished, he handed the notebook to Rachel.
“Can you check the dates against your records?”
She reviewed the pages and corrected one date. Then she returned the notebook.
“You're doing this differently now,” she said.
“What do you mean?”
“You used to tell me what you thought would make the story sound reasonable. Now you're writing down what you actually remember.”
Daniel considered that.
“I spent a long time thinking that if I could explain everything clearly enough, people would believe me.”
“And now?”
“Now I think they should be able to check what I say.”
Rachel nodded slowly.
“That sounds like a better place to start.”
Two days later, Tessa returned to the review office with an attorney.
She had decided to provide the remaining documents through a formal process. Her attorney had reviewed the materials and advised her on which records could be transferred, which required additional authorization, and which should be obtained directly from the department.
The review team accepted the documents under a written receipt and arranged for a technical specialist to examine the electronic files.
Among the records was a spreadsheet containing the status history of several complaints. The spreadsheet did not include the full contents of the complaints, but it showed when their status codes had changed and which accounts had made the changes.
Bennett noticed a pattern.
In several cases, the status had moved from pending review to administratively resolved shortly before the official acknowledgment was issued. In other cases, the status changed back after a supervisor requested clarification.
The pattern was not universal. Many complaints had been processed normally. Some of the changes could be explained by duplicate submissions or incomplete information. Yet the repeated timing suggested that the department's tracking process was more complicated than the official policy described.
“Can we identify the users associated with these changes?” Bennett asked the technical specialist.
“Some of them. The account history is incomplete for the older records. The system retained the status changes but not every underlying authentication event.”
“Why?”
“The retention configuration changed during a software update. The older system didn't preserve all the same details.”
“Was that change documented?”
“There is a technical note, but it doesn't identify who approved the retention settings.”
Evelyn looked at the spreadsheet.
“So we have a system that recorded the outcome of a decision without always preserving who made it.”
“That's correct,” the specialist said.
“And the missing attribution is a known limitation?”
“Yes.”
Evelyn wrote a note.
“Then we need to determine whether that limitation was understood when the system was used to close complaints.”
The specialist nodded.
After the technical team left, Bennett leaned over the spreadsheet.
“This could explain why staff believed a complaint had been handled when the underlying review wasn't visible.”