"Do you regret retiring?"
Carter considered the question.
"I regret not doing more before I left."
Shaw closed her notebook.
"Your statement may help us understand the supervisory culture, but we'll need to verify the incidents and documents you've described."
"I expected that."
"Would you be willing to testify if the investigation leads to formal proceedings?"
Carter looked directly at her.
"Yes."
He stood, gathered his briefcase, and paused at the door.
"There's one more thing I think you should know."
Shaw waited.
"Officer Mercer wasn't the only person who behaved that way. He was one of the most visible examples, but there were others. Some were worse. Some were better officers who made mistakes and then watched supervisors protect them instead of correcting them."
He shook his head.
"If you focus only on Mercer, you'll miss the real problem."
After he left, Shaw remained in the interview room, reviewing the notes she had made.
Carter's statement did not establish that Reeves or Haines had deliberately concealed evidence. It did, however, provide a detailed account of how certain decisions might have become normalized inside the department.
Bennett was right to insist on examining the entire system.
The investigation needed to establish not only what individual officers had done, but also why previous warnings had failed to produce meaningful change.
And now, for the first time, someone with decades of experience inside the department was willing to describe the process from the other side of the desk.
Chief Whitaker received the preliminary summary of Carter's interview that afternoon.
He read it alone in his office, occasionally looking up at the framed photographs on the wall. One showed him shaking hands with recruits at their graduation. Another showed him standing beside officers who had received awards for bravery. A third captured a community meeting at which he had promised that every complaint would receive fair consideration.
He remembered that meeting clearly.
A woman had stood near the back of the room and asked what happened when an officer's report contradicted a citizen's account.
Whitaker had answered that the department reviewed all available evidence and held employees accountable when misconduct was established.
He had believed the answer when he gave it.
Now he wondered how often the department had failed to live up to the promise.
His assistant knocked on the door.
"Deputy Chief Reeves is here."
"Send him in."
Reeves entered without a folder this time.
"Chief, I understand the review team interviewed Samuel Carter."
"They did."
"He retired more than a year ago. I don't see why his personal opinions should be allowed to shape current operations."
Whitaker placed the summary on his desk.
"Did you receive concerns from Carter about complaint handling before he retired?"
Reeves remained standing.
"I remember general discussions about administrative workload."
"Did he specifically raise concerns about the Price case?"
"I don't recall."
"Did he tell you that officers were being discouraged from questioning decisions made by supervisors?"
Reeves frowned.
"That's a broad interpretation of normal management discussions."
"Then help me understand the distinction."
Reeves moved toward the desk.
"Chief, we need to be careful. People who retire sometimes reinterpret ordinary disagreements as evidence of institutional failure. Carter was a good officer, but he wasn't always comfortable with changes in policy."
"Did you examine the concerns he raised?"
"We considered them."
"Where is the documentation?"
Reeves hesitated.
"I would have to check."
Whitaker looked down at the summary.
"That answer is becoming familiar."
"Excuse me?"
"We have multiple cases in which important evidence was requested but not reviewed, complaints were closed without clear documentation, and employees raised concerns that appear to have gone unanswered."
Reeves's expression hardened.
"Are you accusing me of misconduct?"
"I'm asking you to explain your decisions."
"Those are not the same thing."
"Correct. And if you have an explanation, the review team will consider it."
Reeves looked toward the window.
For a moment, the two men appeared to be separated by more than the width of the desk. Whitaker had spent years relying on Reeves's judgment, allowing him to manage daily operations while the chief concentrated on budgets, public relations, and strategic planning.
He had considered that division of responsibility efficient.
He was now beginning to recognize its risks.
"Alan," he said, using the deputy chief's first name, "I need you to understand that I am not asking you to defend the department's reputation. I am asking you to help establish what happened."
Reeves turned back.
"I have spent twenty-five years serving this city."
"I know."
"I have supported officers through difficult situations, defended them against unfair accusations, and made decisions that nobody wanted to make."