This Is Brigadier General Sarah Hayes

Chapter 25

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Paul Hendricks was reached at his desk in the county attorney's office, four streets from the station, with the arrest packet already on its way to him by a deputy told to drive it over and wait.

He read it standing up, the way prosecutors read the first paper in a file that has arrived too fast, the charge first, then the narrative, then the charge again, and then he sat down and read the whole of it a second time with a pencil in his hand. The charge was disorderly conduct. The narrative, in the careful hand he recognized as young Cole's and in flatter, amended language he did not recognize as Cole's at all, described a driver who had declined consent to a search, had stated that she was recording the encounter, and had asked, when told she was under arrest, what the basis of the charge was. It described no shouting, no crowd, no traffic obstructed by the woman herself, no conduct directed at any bystander, because there had been no bystanders on the shoulder of an interstate except two officers of the Winslow County Sheriff's Department. In the margin beside the property line, where a telephone was entered with a description Hendricks read twice, his pencil stopped moving altogether.

He telephoned the station and asked for Brennan, keeping the packet open in front of him, and when the sheriff came on the line Hendricks did not begin with the Army, although the Army's call to his own office, twenty minutes earlier, was the reason a second telephone on his desk was still warm. He began with the stop. "What call dispatched your deputy to that vehicle," he said.

Brennan answered that there had been a report of a suspicious vehicle on the interstate, phoned in that morning, and that Cole had been sent out on it in the ordinary way. Hendricks asked where the call was logged. There was a silence down the line that had paperwork in it. Brennan said that dispatch would have it. Hendricks said he was asking for the log entry, its time and its number, and that he would hold while Brennan found it. He held for some time, and made a note of the length of the hold in the margin of the packet, with the time. When Brennan came back he said that the dispatcher on duty, Bonnie Tate, could not put her hand to a phoned-in report for that stop in the dispatch record, and that it may have come in as a direct observation by the deputy himself. Hendricks wrote that down too, and then he asked his second question. "What disturbance supports this charge, Dale. Name it for me, and name me the witness to it who is not wearing your uniform."

Brennan began to speak about attitude, about noncooperation on the shoulder, about a recording made in a deputy's face, about a driver who had set out to make a scene in front of passing traffic. Hendricks let him finish, because a prosecutor lets a man finish when the man is building the record against himself. Then he said, "A declined search is not a disturbance. A recording is not a disturbance. You have written me a charge whose own narrative acquits it." He turned a page of the packet. "Who witnessed her disorderly conduct. Not who arrested her. Who witnessed it."

Brennan said that Cole had been present throughout and that he, Brennan, had been present for the arrest and could attest to her conduct himself. "Then your witnesses are the arresting officers and no one else on earth," Hendricks said, "and your arresting officer's narrative does not describe the offence, and your complainant is a telephone report that your own dispatch cannot find." He closed the packet. He did not raise his voice at any point, and the absence of heat in it seemed to travel down the line more effectively than heat would have done. "I have had the United States Army on my other line this afternoon, Dale. They were polite. They asked for my name and they wrote it down, and I would advise you to think about what it means when the Army is polite in writing. This county is holding a brigadier general on a charge that its own paperwork will not carry, on a stop that its own dispatch record does not explain. I am coming over there. Nothing further is to be said to her, by you or by anyone, until I am in the building. No one is to interview her, and no paper in that station that touches this morning is to leave that station. Is any part of that unclear to you."

News in the same category

This Is Brigadier General Sarah Hayes

45 Part