His notice, when it came, was the same as every other notice, a sheet with his name and a date and an hour, and the date was four days away. On the last evening before the interview he stayed late at the station on a pretext of paperwork that no one questioned, and when the locker room was empty he opened his locker and took the envelope out and stood with it in his hand under the hard light. He pulled the sheet out far enough to see the first line of his own writing and put it back without unfolding it further. Unfolding it had never been the difficulty. The difficulty stood on either side of the paper like two doors in the same wall. To hand it over was to say, in a room where it would be written down, that the sheet in the station file was not the sheet he had written first, that he had written another at an order he could name, and that he had kept the truth folded in a locker while he wore the same uniform and watched other men go across the street to answer questions to which his envelope was, in part, an answer. It was to become the deputy who had carried paper against his sheriff. To keep it was to answer only what he was asked, in the hope that he would not be asked the one question the sheet existed to answer, and to go on making the same decision one day at a time. He stood a long time with the envelope in his hand. Then he put it back in the locker, exactly where it had lain, and closed the door, and turned the lock, and went out into the yard where his cruiser waited, with the interview still in front of him and the decision still, entire and unmade, in front of that. On the morning of his interview Cole opened his locker before the locker room filled, took the envelope from the shelf where it had lain since the afternoon of the arrest, and put it inside the breast pocket of his uniform shirt, flat against his chest under the flap. He closed the locker, turned the lock, and reported for the start of the shift in the ordinary way. His notice had named an hour in the middle of the morning at the county administration building across the street, and when the hour approached he crossed on foot with his hat in his hand, as the others had done before him, and was shown into the room where the other interviews had been held.
The room had been arranged for the work and for nothing else. There was a table with a recording device at its centre, a pad and a pen at each place, and a box of files on a side chair. Special Agent Naomi Grant sat on the far side with a second agent beside her, a man introduced by name and office who thereafter spoke seldom and wrote much. David Lindqvist sat a little apart, with the file open at the intake papers. Cole was told that a record was being made and that he would be able to read any statement taken from him before he signed it. He said that he understood. He gave his full name, his rank, his length of service, and the duties to which he had been assigned on the day of the stop, and the record took each answer down in order.
The questions at first were the questions he had expected. He was asked to describe the stop, the reason given for it, the checks he had run, and the arrival of the sheriff at the roadside. He answered what he was asked, neither more nor less, in short sentences that surprised him by their steadiness. He was asked to describe the transport to Dunmore and the intake, the hour of it, the clear plastic property bin, and the order in which the property had been placed in it. He described the bin and its contents item by item, and when he named the telephone he named it as a telephone and said nothing, yet, about any paper. He was asked who had been present at intake, who had given what direction, and what forms had been completed. He answered each question as it came, and the envelope lay against his chest the whole while, present in every answer he gave by the fact that he had not yet spoken of it.
Lindqvist turned a page in the file and laid a copy of a property intake sheet on the table, only far enough that Cole could read it without reaching. It was the replacement sheet, the sheet that stood in the station file, with the entry for the telephone written in the amended form, the description shortened to the words that invited no questions and the serial number absent altogether. Grant asked him whether that was the intake sheet for the arrest in question, whether the handwriting on it was his, and whether it was the sheet he had written at intake itself. Cole looked at the copy for longer than the reading of it required. The handwriting was his, and it would have been possible, even then, to answer the first two questions and let the third be carried along inside them, unexamined. Grant waited, and did not fill the silence. In the quiet he understood that the decision he had carried unmade for weeks would be made in the next sentence he spoke, whichever sentence it was.