He said that the handwriting was his and that the sheet in front of him was a sheet he had written, but that it was not the first sheet. He said there was another sheet, the first one, written in ink at intake, at the time, before that one, and that he had it. He said it without raising his voice, and when he had said it he reached, slowly and with his hands in plain view, to the flap of his breast pocket, took the envelope out, and laid it on the table between himself and Grant, and then placed his hands flat on either side of his pad. No one reached for the envelope at once. Grant asked whether it contained the sheet he had described. He said that it did. She asked when he had last opened it and whether its contents had been altered, added to, or copied since the day it was written. He said he had opened it once, on the evening before, far enough to see the first line of his own writing, and that it had not been altered or copied and had been in no hands but his own since it was written. Only then did she draw the envelope toward her and noted the time on her pad.
What followed was done in an order Cole would remember afterward more distinctly than the moment of decision itself, because the order was the meaning of it. The envelope was photographed where it lay, front and back, with a scale card beside it and the photograph number spoken aloud for the record. The second agent put on gloves, opened the envelope, and photographed the sheet in its folded state before it was opened flat under the light. Grant read its entries aloud, slowly, for the recording. The telephone was listed with its serial number, figure by figure and letter by letter, and beside it, in his own handwriting, in ink, stood the description as it had been given to him at the counter, that it was a secured device and United States Government property. The other items stood below it in order, the wallet, the credentials, the folded orders, and at the foot of the sheet stood the hour he had written at the time, and his own initials. No one commented on the reading. Grant laid the sheet inside a clear sleeve, and the sleeve was closed, and the time was noted again.
He was then asked, from the beginning of the paper and not from its end, to account for both sheets. He did so. He said he had written the first sheet at intake as the property was placed in the bin, entering the telephone as it had been described to him and recording its serial number from the device itself. He said Sheriff Brennan had thereafter directed him to strike that entry and to write a replacement sheet on which the telephone would appear in the shortened form and without a serial number, so that the paperwork would invite no outside questions. He said he had written the replacement as directed and placed it in the file, and that he had not destroyed the first sheet, as he understood he had been expected in due course to do, but had folded it and kept it, first in his pocket and then in an envelope in his locker, where it had remained until that morning. He named the place, the locker, and the interval, and he named the order and the man who had given it, once, in answer to a direct question, and then again when the passage was read back to him. He said no other person, to his knowledge, had known he had kept it.
The statement was taken down as he spoke, in the second agent's hand and in the recording together. When he had finished, the draft was printed in the adjoining office and brought back to him, and he read it through at the table, pen in hand, while the others waited without conversation. Twice he stopped and asked that a word be corrected, and both corrections were made in his presence and initialled by him in the margin. He then signed each page at its foot and signed the last page below the declaration that the statement was true to the best of his knowledge and belief and that he had made it of his own accord. A copy was made for him before he left the room, and he folded it once and put it in the same breast pocket from which the envelope had come, so that he crossed the street back to the station with paper in the pocket still, but with paper of a different kind.