The afternoon went by like a held breath. We ate gas station sandwiches in the car. We drank his brother's coffee. We took turns sleeping in twenty-minute scraps while the other one watched, and every car that slowed near our house made my whole body go tight as a wire.
"You know we could still be wrong," David said once, around nine, when the street had gone fully dark and quiet. "He could just be a lonely old man who misses his house. We could be two lunatics sitting in the dark, spying on a neighbor."
"I know," I said. "If he's innocent, then all he is is kind, and I'll spend the rest of my life being ashamed of this weekend. I can live with that. I can't live with the other one."
He nodded and took my hand, and we went back to watching our own porch the way you watch a door you are afraid will open.
Eleven came. Eleven thirty. The street emptied. Mrs. Abernathy's porch light went off across the road, and somewhere far away a dog barked itself out, and our house sat dark and patient with its one lit window, and I had just begun to hate myself for all of it when David's hand closed hard around mine.
"There," he breathed.
A man was coming down the sidewalk on the far side of the street, unhurried, in a dark jacket with the collar up. He crossed at the corner of our lot without looking left or right, the way a man crosses a road he has crossed a thousand times in the dark.
He had a grocery bag in each arm, the white plastic kind, full and sagging. Hanging from the fingers of one hand, swinging a little as he walked, was a big plastic water jug, the gallon kind, full by the way it pulled his arm straight.
He did not go to the front steps and knock, the way a neighbor checking on pipes would knock. He went up our driveway like he owned the stones of it, took out a key — his key, the spare he had kept "for emergencies" — and fitted it into our front door in the dark without fumbling, without a light, without one second of hesitation.
The door opened. The dark of the house took him in, grocery bags, water jug and all, the way a mouth takes food.
The door closed behind him so softly that if I had not been staring at it I would never have believed it had moved at all. My watch said eleven fifty-eight.
"He's in our house," I whispered.
David did not answer. He was holding my hand so tightly it ached, and neither of us looked away from our own dark windows for even a second.
He was in there an hour. I know because I watched the minutes go by on the dashboard clock like they were beads on a string, and every single one of them asked me the same question: what in God's name is he doing in our house for an hour, in the dark, with groceries?
David wanted to go in after twenty minutes. I held onto his sleeve and would not let him.
"If we go in now, he says he was checking the pipes and heard a noise, and we're the crazy new people who attacked their neighbor in the night," I whispered. "We wait. We watch what he carries out. That's the whole story, whatever he carries out."
So we waited, and the house gave us nothing — no light in any window, no shadow crossing the timer lamp's glow, nothing. Whoever Frank Delaney was inside our walls at midnight, he did not need light to do it. He knew that house the way you know your own body.
At twelve fifty-six the front door opened again, so softly, and he came out backwards the way a man comes out of a place he is used to leaving in the dark.
I saw the bags first. Both of them, one in each arm — and both of them flat. Empty. Crushed down to nothing, the plastic wrinkled and weightless, swinging loose against his sides like skins. The water jug hung from his fingers, and even in the dark I could see it was empty too, bouncing light against his leg as he walked.
He pulled our door shut. He locked it. He stood a moment on our porch with his head bowed, like a man leaving a church, and then he walked down our driveway and away into the dark toward his own street, carrying nothing at all.
We gave him twenty minutes. We gave him twenty-five, sitting in that ticking, cooling car, while David's hands opened and closed on the steering wheel. Then we drove once around the block, parked his brother's car two streets over, and walked home to our own house on foot, in the dark, feeling like burglars in a story someone else was telling.
My key sounded obscenely loud in our lock. The house smelled exactly the way it had smelled when we left it — cleaner, coffee, the lemon oil I use on the banister — and that ordinariness scared me more than anything had all night. Nothing was disturbed. Nothing was out of place. A man had spent an hour in my home in the dark and left it looking loved.
We went to Noah's room first anyway, the way you check a sleeping child's breathing. His bed was made. His drawings were stacked on the dresser where he had left them. The room looked entirely ordinary, and that was the worst of it — my son had been sleeping six feet from whatever this was, and it had worn a face this ordinary.