We went through it room by room, whispering, not turning on lights, using David's phone like a candle. Kitchen: untouched. Bathroom: dry. The fuse box: closed. And then we came to the hall outside Noah's bedroom, and I stopped so fast David walked into my back.
"Smell that," I said.
He stood still beside me in the dark. "Food," he said slowly. "Something hot. Soup?"
It was tomato soup, I'd have sworn it in court, and warm bread under it, faint and steamy and impossible, leaking out of the little ventilation grate low on Noah's bedroom wall — the old grate Noah pressed his ear to, the one that carried the crying through. Somewhere on the other side of that wall, in the last hour, in the dark, somebody had been fed a hot meal.
David crouched. I crouched beside him with my face near the grate and I breathed in soup and warm air that had recently held a human being's dinner, and I started to shake so hard my teeth knocked together.
I put my mouth close to the grate, close enough to feel that used, warm air on my lips. "Lily?" I whispered. Nothing came back. Not a breath, not a knock. Just silence — the particular silence of someone who has been trained, the way you train an animal, that survival means making no sound at all.
"Sarah." David's phone light had moved away from me, down to the floor at the hall closet. "Look at this. Look at the floor here. Has that always been there?"
The hall closet stood at the end of the corridor, an ordinary narrow door we kept coats and the vacuum in.
Along the baseboard in front of it, and across the floorboards at its threshold, the pale wood was scored with fresh scuff marks — dark, bright-edged scrapes, dozens of them, the kind made by something heavy being dragged or worked back and forth in the same small patch of floor, again and again, over time.
The varnish was worn through in an arc exactly as wide as the closet door.
David ran two fingers along the deepest scrape and held them up to the phone light. Fresh splinters clung to his skin. "This is not old," he said. "Some of these marks are weeks old. Some of them might be from tonight."
I knew my own house. I had scrubbed those floors on my hands and knees in April. Those marks were not there in April. Those marks were the tracks of a door that got opened in the dark, in secret, over and over, by someone standing exactly where I was now kneeling.
I called my mother from the kitchen because I could not stand in that hallway another second, and because it was one in the morning and I needed to hear my son exist.
Mom said he had gone down easy after his pancakes, and then she said, "He wanted to tell you something before bed, honey. He's been asking all evening. Hold on."
There was a rustle, and then Noah's voice, thick with sleep, in my ear: "Mommy?"
"I'm here, baby."
"Lily is scared tonight," he said, with the complete, level certainty of a child reporting the weather. "She said the man is coming with the bags, and she has to be very, very quiet, so I was quiet too, all day. Did you knock for me, Mommy? I couldn't knock from Grandma's."
I sat down on my kitchen floor in the dark, in my burgled, soup-smelling house, and I promised my son that I would knock. And I understood, with a clarity that felt like falling, that I was done waiting for anyone's permission to find out what was inside my wall.
It rained the next night, a steady Oregon rain that started at dusk and settled in like it meant to stay, and I was glad of it. Rain covers noise. Rain keeps streets empty. Rain keeps helpful neighbors with spare keys in their own houses, watching television, believing the young family from 14 Willow Lane is two days away at the coast.
Noah stayed at my mother's for a third night. I had called her that morning and said only that the house business was taking longer than we thought, and she — who had heard her grandson's report about a girl in a wall and had not laughed once — said, "Then he stays with me until it's finished, Sarah," and that was that.
David brought the sledgehammer up from the garage at nine o'clock and laid it on the kitchen table between us, and we looked at it the way you look at a loaded decision.
"If she's not there," he said, "we've destroyed a wall in a house we can barely afford, because our five-year-old has an imaginary friend, and we are exactly the lunatics I said."
"And if she is there?" I said.
He picked up the hammer. "Then God help us for every day we laughed."
Before we touched the closet, I went into Noah's room and stood in the dark where his bed was, and I put my palm flat against the wall over his pillow, the way he did. "We're coming," I whispered to the plaster. "Whoever you are. We heard you. We're coming." The wall said nothing, and I took my hand off it and went to work.
We started where the scuff marks were. I think some part of me had known since the night before that it would be the hall closet — the worn arc on the floorboards had been drawing my eyes like a magnet all day, a little map of a secret standing in plain sight in our corridor.
David emptied the closet in silence, coats and vacuum and board games stacked in the hall, and then he stood inside that narrow space with the hammer and looked at the back panel, ordinary painted boards that rang — oh, God, they rang hollow, they had probably always rung hollow, and we had hung our coats against them and never once thought about it.