We argued about it in the careful, low voices of people who have recently learned how sound travels through walls.
What settled it was Noah, who had not been consulted and consulted himself.
His grandmother mentioned, in passing and with the best intentions, a new house with a bigger yard, and Noah informed her, in the tone of a small building inspector, that his room was not finished yet because the garden part had not been built, and anyway Lily knew this house, and she could not learn a whole new one.
David looked at me over his son's head and I looked at David, and that was the meeting. We were keeping the house. We were not going to hand it back to the man who had built a secret into it. We were going to heal it in place, like a bone.
Demolition day, David did himself.
He would not hire it out. He said that as long as he lived he was not paying another man to open that wall, and he took the plans he had drawn at the kitchen table, the new ones, with the window where the hidden room had breathed, and he pinned them up in the hallway like a promise the house had to keep.
Noah was at my mother's. Some things a child does not need to watch, even a child who started everything.
I stood in the doorway of the little bedroom with coffee neither of us drank and watched my husband take down the room Frank built. He worked methodically at first, the architect, prying trim, stacking boards, keeping it clean.
Then he got to the back of it, to the narrow space itself, stripped now of everything the police had taken away, just studs and dust and the smell that old closed places keep, and his method went out of him all at once.
He hit it with the sledgehammer the way you hit a thing that hid your son's friend in the dark for eight years.
I did not stop him. I went and got the other hammer out of the garage, the smaller one, and I hit it too, and for a while the house rang like a bell with the two of us in it, breaking the most careful piece of work Frank Delaney ever did into kindling and dust and nothing.
By evening there was no room. That is the sentence I had wanted to be able to say for months, and I said it out loud to the studs and the rubble. There was no room, there had never, in any way that mattered anymore, been permission for a room.
There was just the skeleton of a house, standing open to the weather on one side, with the light coming through in a way it had not come through since before she was seven.
The window went in the following week, a big one, where the hidden room used to back onto the world.
David put it there on purpose and bigger than the plan strictly needed, in the wall between Noah's bedroom and what would become the garden, so that the first thing that room did every morning was look outside. The framers thought he was mad to want it that size. He signed the change order without blinking.
The first morning after it was finished, I found Noah awake before his alarm, sitting up in bed in a bar of sunlight so wide it had its own geography, with his drawings spread around him like a small country.
He breathed in, experimentally, the way he does when he is checking a fact for a report he intends to deliver.
"It smells like outside now," he said.
I sat down on the edge of the bed in the sun. The air coming through the cracked window had the green smell of the lane after watering, and somebody's sprinklers, and warm wood.
The room had sounded different ever since the wall came down, too — bigger in the ear, as if it had been holding its breath for years and had finally, finally been allowed to let it go.
"Is that good?" I asked him. "Smelling like outside?"
"It means the wall is just a wall," Noah said, with enormous satisfaction, and went back to his drawing, which was a house, I noticed, with a window in every wall and a door standing open, drawn in the yellow crayon he saves for suns and other important things.
We painted his room a pale green that David called sage and Noah called leaf. We put the bed back, and the bookshelf, and the rug with the roads on it.
We left the vent grate in the garage in a box of things for the police, and then, when the police said we could have it back or not as we pleased, we did not please, and it went out with the trash on a Tuesday and nobody watched it go.
The house got loud again the way a house is supposed to be loud. Pipes knocked — real pipes, honest pipes, which we verified like lunatics the first three times and then learned to ignore. The refrigerator hummed its one note.
Noah sang to himself through every room, a small one-man weather system, and every time my heart jumped at a sound from that end of the house it jumped less, until one evening I realized I had heard him knock his toy truck against the baseboard three times running and felt nothing but mild annoyance about the paint.