We Moved Into Our Dream House, But My 5-Year-Old Son Kept Talking To A Little Girl Through His Bedroom Wall — Then One Night I Heard Her Answer Him From Inside It

Chapter 31

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"There are eight of them in this notebook, Your Honor," the prosecutor said. "One in every December section, eight years running. The State will show that the victim drew a Christmas tree every single year." She let the silence do the rest of it. "She never saw one. She remembered what one looked like from being seven, and she drew it from that, every year, in the dark."

I looked at Frank then. I had avoided looking at him all morning, the way you avoid looking at a drop off a cliff path. He sat very still in his chair with his hands folded, and for the first time since I'd known him his face had nothing arranged on it. No neighborly warmth. No wounded innocence. Just a man listening to arithmetic he had made.

His lawyer objected twice more before the hearing ended, about the trees, of all things — relevance, prejudice — and the judge overruled him in a voice that had run out of patience entirely. When the admissibility of the drawings was confirmed, Frank leaned to his lawyer and whispered something urgent and fast, and his lawyer shook his head once, slowly, without looking at him.

The judge found probable cause on every count the State had brought. Kidnapping. False imprisonment. The forged note, which the handwriting expert would speak to another day. Child endangerment running on into years I still couldn't say out loud without stopping. Frank Delaney would stand trial for all of it, and the notebook would go with him into that trial, trees and all.

The State also entered the old listing for our house, the glossy brochure from years of owners ago, with the back bedroom measured out at fourteen feet, and laid it beside the measurements taken in April. Ten feet of room. Fourteen feet of house. Four feet of a child's life, accounted for on a single sheet of paper, in a column of cheerful real-estate print.

Outside on the courthouse steps, Rachel stood in the weak sun with her coat unbuttoned, holding her purse in both hands like a hymn book. "She counted," she said to me, and her voice broke on it cleanly. "All those years I was lighting candles, she was counting. We were both keeping track.

Neither of us stopped."

Mrs. Abernathy telephoned me on a Tuesday evening, at the hotel, and apologized three times before she told me why she had called. Her voice was thin and formal, the voice of a woman who had written thank-you notes her whole life. "I need to tell someone the true thing," she said.

"And then I need to tell it to the police, in the right order."

Eleanor Abernathy was seventy-nine and lived directly across Willow Lane from our house, in the blue cottage with the porch she swept every morning at seven. She had watched us move in. She had waved at Frank for fifteen years. She asked me to come to her kitchen, because some things, she said, should not be said into a telephone.

Our house stood across the street from hers with its blinds drawn, quiet as a held breath. The police tape was long gone by then, but nobody on Willow Lane walked on our side of the street that spring. They crossed at the corner, the way you cross to avoid a house where someone has died.

I sat at her table with tea I didn't drink while the light went down over our street, and she told me about a summer evening eight years ago, when her windows stood open against the heat, before she had the air conditioning her son had since insisted on. She had heard crying from the house across the street. A child's crying. Not loud.

Patient, almost, the way children cry when they have already learned nobody is coming quickly.

"I told myself it was a television," she said. "Then I told myself it was the little girl's cousins, visiting, having a tantrum about bedtime. I had a whole supper of explanations, Sarah. I cooked them up one after another because the real one was too terrible to sit down at the table with."

The next day she had crossed the street with a jar of her preserves, because that is what her generation knocked on doors with, and she had asked Frank, as lightly as she could manage, whether everything was all right in the house. She had heard a child crying in the night, she'd said. She remembered his answer word for word.

She had carried it word for word for eight years.

"He laughed," she said. "He put his hand right here, on the wall by the door, like he was patting a dog, and he said, 'Eleanor, this old house sings. It's the pipes. They carry on something awful in the summer.' And I believed him, because he had a kind face and a laugh ready, and because believing him cost me nothing."

She was quiet a moment, turning her cup in its saucer. "It would have cost me something to not believe him. That's the part I've had to look at. It would have cost me the whole street being wrong about a man we all liked. So I paid nothing, and a child paid everything. I heard her, Sarah.

I want it written down somewhere official that I heard her, and that I walked back across the street."

She was not the only one who called Detective Quinn that month. A man at the end of the lane, whose name I never did learn, told her he had assumed for years that Frank kept a night job none of us knew about, because of the car, always the car, two and three in the morning, headlights sweeping the bedroom ceilings of the street like a lighthouse nobody wanted.

News in the same category

We Moved Into Our Dream House, But My 5-Year-Old Son Kept Talking To A Little Girl Through His Bedroom Wall — Then One Night I Heard Her Answer Him From Inside It

45 Part