Because there were details. That is the thing nobody warns you about: the details were wrong for an imaginary friend, in ways that piled up quietly, like dust on a shelf you keep meaning to wipe.
Imaginary friends, in my experience of Noah, were flamboyant. His friend at the apartment had been a purple bear who drove a bus. The wall girl had no color, no name, no games. She did not want anything Noah had. She only ever asked questions, and cried.
And she kept office hours. That sounds strange, but it is the truth. She was never there in the daytime, when I sat in his room folding his clothes or reading him stories in the sun. She came when the house went dark and quiet, and Noah was alone in his bed with his back to the wall.
"She has to be quiet in the day," Noah explained, when I asked why she never talked at lunch. "Daytime is the dangerous time. She told me."
"The dangerous time," I repeated.
"For being heard," he said, and then the school bus of the conversation moved on, the way it does with five-year-olds, and he was asking for a second helping of macaroni.
That night I did something I had not done before. After David was asleep, I stood outside Noah's door with my ear nearly to the wood, holding my breath like a girl at a sleepover, and I listened to my son comfort somebody.
"It's okay," Noah was saying, soft as anything. "Don't cry. My mommy makes soup when I'm sad. She's a good cooker. She can make you soup too, if you come out."
There was a pause. Noah listened, his head cocked — I could hear the little shift of him against the pillow. Then he said, more quietly, "I can't open it. I don't know how. I'm only five."
I went back to bed with my whole skin prickling and told no one. In the morning I laughed at David's joke about her at the breakfast table, bright and normal, and I hated myself for the laugh before the coffee was even poured.
By the end of the second week, the girl in the wall had a schedule, a temperament, and rules, and my son kept her confidences like a little priest. Every morning at breakfast he delivered her news the way other children deliver dreams.
"She slept a little," he would report. "She had the dream about the stairs again. She doesn't like the dream about the stairs."
I started, without deciding to, keeping a list in my phone. Dates, times, the exact sentences Noah carried out of that room. I told myself it was for the pediatrician. I told myself a lot of things that spring, and most of them had costumes on.
Her name arrived on a Tuesday, in the middle of an argument about shoes. Noah was sitting on the hall floor working a sneaker over his heel, and he said, without looking up, with total casualness, "Lily says you're loud too, in the mornings."
The kitchen went quiet in a way I can still hear. David lowered his newspaper. "Lily," he said. "The wall friend has a name now."
"She always had a name," Noah said, deeply offended. "I just didn't ask before. You have to ask. It's rude not to ask."
I crouched down beside him with his other shoe in my hand. "That's a pretty name," I said carefully. "Lily. Did she tell you anything else about herself?"
"She's big," Noah said. "Bigger than me. Not grown-up big. In-between big." He held his hand up at about the height of my chin, considered it, moved it a little higher. "Like that. She sounds like that big."
An imaginary friend his own age would have made sense. A purple bear made sense. A girl who was in-between big, in the wall, with rules about daytime — I filed it away in the drawer of my mind where I was keeping all the other things I did not want to look at in the light.
David's explanation grew to fit, the way explanations do when a family needs them. Noah had heard the name somewhere. A cartoon. A kid at preschool. The world is wall-to-wall with names, and Lily is a common one. He was right about that. He was right about everything, and it did not help me at all.
Because then Noah started bringing out her sentences whole, like messages in a bottle, and some of them had no business in a five-year-old's mouth.
"She says it is always dark where she is," he told me one night, while I was tucking the blanket up under his chin. He said it simply, the way he would tell me the bathwater was cold. "Even when it's morning. She says morning doesn't come in there."
"Noah." I kept my hand on the blanket. "What does she mean, where she is?"
"Her room," he said. "It's very little. She can touch both sides." He stretched his arms out in the bed, one hand toward the wall, one toward the room, measuring. "Like that, but littler. She has to sit a lot."
"Does she ever go outside her room? To a yard, or a kitchen?"
He looked at me like I had suggested the moon was made of cheese. "There's no outside," he said. "There's just the door part. And the door part doesn't open. It only opens when the food comes."
I want to write down that I ran to David that minute. I did not. I sat on the edge of my son's bed in the blue night-light glow and smoothed his hair and said, "That sounds lonely," and Noah nodded, gracious as a king, and said, "That's why I talk to her. Nobody else talks to her. She said I'm the first one who ever talked back."