The first one who ever talked back. I lay awake until two that night turning that sentence over like a stone in my pocket, looking for the angle where it was nothing. Kids say things. Kids absorb things. Somewhere he had heard a story, a show, something at preschool with a sad girl in a sad place, and his big heart had moved in and furnished it.
But here is what I kept coming back to, in the dark, with David breathing beside me: Noah was a child who exaggerated everything. If a dog was big, it was a giant dog, a house-sized dog. If he was hungry, he was starving to death, dramatically, at the table, with a spoon in his fist.
His friend in the wall never got bigger. She stayed the size of the truth, in every report: a room she could touch both sides of, a door that only opened for food, a dark where morning did not come. Imaginary things grow in the telling. That is their whole nature. Hers never grew. She only ever got more specific.
There were nights I almost knocked. I can admit it now. I would stand in the hallway after he fell asleep, with my knuckles an inch from that wall — the wall Frank had warned us about, with its wiring and its asbestos and its history of trouble — and I would think: if I knock, and something knocks back, then it is real, and my whole life changes tonight.
And if nothing knocks back, I would think, then I am a woman standing in the dark knocking on walls, and my son has an imaginary friend, and everything is fine.
I never knocked. That spring, I never knocked. I want the record to show that I was a coward in the ordinary way, the way most people are: not running from danger, just very politely declining to find out.
Instead, I watched. I watched Noah draw at the kitchen table while I cooked, his tongue poking out in concentration. I watched him keep his ear turned, always, slightly, toward the back of the house, the way you listen for a baby in another room even after the baby is asleep.
And one evening, when David was late and the rain was coming down hard enough to make the gutters argue, Noah said the thing that moved the whole business, finally, out of the drawer in my mind.
"She's scared tonight," he said, out of nowhere, over his chicken nuggets. "Extra scared. She says when it rains hard, the water comes in her room, and he gets mad about the water." He took a sip of milk. "She says please don't tell him she's loud. She says he counts it."
"Counts what, baby?"
"The loud," Noah said.
I put my fork down. "Noah. Who is he?"
But the school bus had moved on. He was asking whether dinosaurs had birthdays, and Lily and her rain and her counting man went back behind the wall where they lived, and I sat at my own table in my own warm kitchen and felt the house around me go strange and unfamiliar, like a room you have lived in for years and suddenly see from the wrong end.
Frank became a fixture of our spring the way weather is a fixture — you stopped remarking on it. It seemed entirely natural, by May, that his truck should slow past our curb, that his knock should come with a bag of tomatoes or a wrench already in his hand.
He fixed the porch board he had promised us, on his knees, with his own screws. He showed David how to coax the furnace through its moods. He unclogged the bathroom sink with a tool I have never seen before or since, and refused, laughing, all payment but coffee.
He mended the gate latch without being asked. He pushed Noah on the tire swing David had hung from the oak, and Noah shrieked with joy, and Frank laughed with his whole face, and I stood at the kitchen window with a dish towel in my hands thinking that suspicion is an ugly thing to feel toward a man pushing your child on a swing.
"You folks are doing the old girl a kindness just by living in her," he would say, patting the door frame like a horse's neck. "Houses go sad when they're empty. She perked right up when your boy started running her halls."
When David had the flu he arrived with soup in a pot he insisted we keep until it stood empty. When Noah had a cough there were lemons on the porch by morning. Kindness came off that man like weather off the sea, constant and unasked, and it is a humbling thing to set your doubts in a row against a pot of soup.
People on the street adored him. Mrs. Abernathy across the road, seventy-nine and sharp as a tack in most things, told me over the fence that we had lucked into the best neighbor in Oregon, a man who had suffered and stayed sweet.
"Lost his wife," she confided. "And the little girl ran off, years back, his stepdaughter. Broke him clean in half, and still he brings me soup when my hip acts up. There's not many like Frank Delaney."
I said what you say. I said how awful, and how kind he was, and I carried the words home with me and turned them over in the night: the little girl ran off. A stepdaughter. Years back. I told myself it was a coincidence, and the word coincidence felt thinner every time I used it.
Because Frank's kindness had a geography to it, and I was slowly learning the map. He was generous everywhere in the house except at one end of it. He never once, in all his visits, walked down our hall and into Noah's room.