Deborah read the last line twice. Then she walked to the window and looked out at the gray December sky, and she thought about reels of brown tape in a lawyer's office safe, and about church bells at nine o'clock, and about a boy learning to breathe through a phrase while a building burned above him.
"Materially alter the facts," she said to the empty kitchen. "Just you wait."
Β
The snow started before dawn on the morning of the hearing and was still falling when Deborah drove her father downtown, the windshield wipers beating a slow rhythm and the radio off because neither of them could stand the sound of anyone talking about them anymore.
The courthouse steps were already crowded β reporters with their collars up, two television cameras under plastic hoods, a knot of theatre people Frankie Domino had organized, holding no signs, just standing there in the snow as a kind of testimony. Deborah saw Dana Whitfield and looked the other way. She linked her arm through her father's, and they climbed the steps together, and the cameras followed them all the way up.
Inside, the hallway smelled of wet wool and floor wax. Michael O'Connell was waiting outside the courtroom with his briefcase, and he shook Elias's hand like a man greeting a friend, not a client.
"Ready?" he asked.
"I have been ready since October," Elias said.
The courtroom was smaller than Deborah had expected. The judge β Harriet Lang, sixty, gray hair in a knot, a reputation for running a courtroom like a metronome β took the bench at nine sharp, and the bailiff called the case, and Frances Doyle rose to speak for the state.
Doyle was forty-five, precise, the kind of prosecutor who never raised her voice because she never needed to. She laid out the state's case the way a carpenter lays out tools: each piece in its place, each one clean.
"This is a case about keys, money, and a coat," she said. "On the night of October sixteenth, during the Majestic Theatre's autumn gala, a fire was set in the theatre's storage room at approximately nine twenty-three in the evening. The gala's cash box, containing approximately eighteen thousand dollars in receipts, was stolen. The defendant, Elias Grant, was the theatre's night janitor. Two master keys to the building existed. One was held by the theatre's manager. The other was held by the defendant."
She paused, and the courtroom was very quiet.
"In September of this year, the defendant paid off a gambling debt of forty-two hundred dollars β a debt fifteen years old, paid in a single sum, from sources the defendant has never explained. At approximately nine o'clock that evening, the theatre's doorman saw a man in a janitor's coat near the storage room corridor."
"Finally," Doyle said, and now she lifted a sheet of paper from the counsel table and held it up, "the defendant's own time sheet for October sixteenth, initialed by him. It shows him beginning his rounds at seven p.m. β alone, unobserved, with a master key in his pocket and every room in the building open to him. From seven o'clock until the alarm at nine twenty-three, no one can say where Elias Grant was. Except Mr. Krueger, who saw his coat."
She sat down. Deborah felt her father's arm tense beside her, and she put her hand over his. On the paper in Doyle's hand she could see, even from the second row, the small neat initials her father put on everything he touched β E.G., careful as a signature on a photograph.
O'Connell stood. "The defense will show," he said, "that keys can be borrowed, that debts can be paid honestly, and that a coat is not a man."
The doorman took the stand just after ten. His name was Walt Krueger, he was fifty-eight, and he had worked the Majestic's stage door for nine years. He wore his best suit and kept smoothing his tie, and he answered Doyle's questions in a voice that carried clearly to the back of the room.
"Mr. Krueger," Doyle said, "on the night of October sixteenth, at approximately nine o'clock, did you see anyone near the storage room corridor?"
"Yes, ma'am. I saw a man in a janitor's gray coat. He went around the corner toward the storage rooms. I didn't think anything of it at the time β janitors go everywhere in that building."
"Did you see his face?"
Krueger hesitated. "Not β not clearly, ma'am. It was dim back there. The coat, though. I know that coat."
"Thank you, Mr. Krueger." Doyle sat down, and Deborah felt something cold settle in her stomach, because it had sounded so certain, so clean.
O'Connell rose slowly and walked to the witness stand with his hands in his pockets, the way he did when he wanted a witness to forget he was a lawyer.
"Mr. Krueger," he said gently, "you've known Elias Grant nine years. Would you say you know his face?"
"Oh, yes, sir."
"If you had seen Elias Grant's face that night, going around that corner, you would have recognized him?"
"Yes, sir, I believe I would."
"But you didn't see his face."
"No, sir."
"You saw a coat."
Krueger shifted in his chair. "The coat, yes, sir."
"Mr. Krueger, where do the janitors' coats hang when they're not being worn?"
"In the utility closet, sir. By the stage door. On hooks."
"How many coats?"
"Three or four. Gray ones. All alike."
"And is that closet locked, Mr. Krueger?"
"No, sir. It's just a closet."
"So any staff member, any contractor, anyone with access to the stage door area could take one of those coats off a hook and put it on."
Krueger looked at Doyle, then back at O'Connell. "I suppose β yes, sir. I suppose they could."
"And in the week before the fire, Mr. Krueger, was there a contractor working in the building? A man named Larry Pruitt, doing electrical work?"
"Yes, sir. He was around most days."
"Did Mr. Pruitt have access to the stage door area?"
"He β yes, sir. He came and went."
O'Connell nodded, as if Krueger had just confirmed the weather. "One more question, Mr. Krueger. That night, at nine o'clock, when you saw the coat go around the corner β did you see the man's hands?"
"His hands? No, sir."
"Trumpet players have distinctive hands, Mr. Krueger. Calluses. Elias Grant played trumpet professionally for twenty years. You didn't notice the hands."
"No, sir."