At the theatre itself, which stood boarded and smelling of wet char behind the police tape, the staff split down the middle and then split again. Frankie Domino, a stagehand with twenty years in, carried a petition around in his lunch pail and got forty-one signatures from carpenters, electricians, ushers, and two of the gala's own waiters β men and women who wrote, in various hands, that Elias Grant had once carried a sick usher down three flights of stairs and had never taken so much as a program without asking. But the head usher wouldn't sign, and two of the wardrobe women crossed Delmar to avoid Frankie on the sidewalk, and a gala patron named Mrs. Albright wrote a letter to the Ledger saying she had seen the janitor herself that night, wheeling his cart through the lobby with an expression she described, from a distance of forty feet, as "guilty."
Deborah read that letter aloud to her father one evening and he laughed β a short, surprised sound, the first time she had heard him laugh since October.
"She saw me wheeling my cart," he said. "That is what I do. I wheel my cart. Forty feet away she could tell I was guilty. Lord."
On a Thursday evening in the middle of the month, when the light went early and the radiators knocked, there was a knock at the apartment door that wasn't the police and wasn't a reporter. It was Cleveland Pryor, sixty-four years old, a bassist Elias had played with in rooms that no longer existed, carrying a paper grocery bag in each arm and wearing a coat with the lining coming out at the cuffs.
"Deborah," Cleveland said, as if they had seen each other yesterday instead of at her mother's funeral six years back. "You got taller. Your daddy shrunk."
"Cleveland Pryor," Elias said from the kitchen doorway, and the two old men looked at each other for a long moment, and then they embraced the way men of their generation did, hard and brief, as if hugging too long might be mistaken for something it wasn't.
Cleveland set the bags on the counter β collards, cornmeal, a ham hock, coffee β and waved off Deborah's thanks. "I eat at my sister's. This is for a man who looks like he been living on newspapers." He settled into the good chair and looked around the small front room, at the trumpet case on top of the bookshelf, at the framed photograph of a young Elias in a white dinner jacket holding that trumpet like it was a living thing.
"You still got it," Cleveland said.
"I still got it."
"When's the last time you played it?"
Elias was quiet. "Your guess is as good as mine."
They talked then the way old musicians talk, which is mostly about other musicians β who was where, who had passed, who was playing Sundays at a church on the north side and sounding better than ever. Deborah moved around the kitchen making the collards, and she listened, and she understood that this was Cleveland's gift: an hour in which her father was not a suspect, but a trumpeter.
Later, when the dishes were done and Cleveland was putting on his coat, he stood at the door and said, "Elias. I want to say something and then I won't say it again. I know you didn't do it."
"Clevelandβ"
"I know you didn't do it because in forty years I never once heard you lie about music. Not about a tempo, not about a key, not about whether the second set was any good. A man who can't lie about a tempo can't burn down a theatre for money. That's my whole testimony and you can quote me."
After he left, Elias stood at the window watching him walk to the bus stop, and Deborah came and stood beside him, and neither of them said anything for a while.
The reporter found Deborah on the Tuesday before Thanksgiving, waiting by the teachers' parking lot at Carver with a photographer who kept his camera at his side like a promise he hadn't decided whether to keep.
"Miss Grant? Dana Whitfield, the Ledger. Just a few questions about your father."
Deborah kept walking. "I have nothing to say to the Ledger."
"Your father had a gambling debt, Miss Grant. Four thousand dollars. Paid off in September. Where does a night janitor get that kind of money?"
Deborah stopped. The photographer lifted his camera and she looked straight into it, and later she would be angrier at herself for that than for anything she said.
"My father had a debt fifteen years ago," she said, each word placed like a brick. "He paid it off over years, a little at a time, and he finished in September. You know that because the police told you. What the police didn't tell you is that he paid it with overtime and with the money he saved when he stopped playing clubs to raise me. You print that, Miss Whitfield, or you print nothing about my father at all."
"Is it true the theatre board is voting to demolish the Majestic?"
"Ask the board." Deborah got into her car. The photographer took the picture anyway β her hand up, her mouth open mid-word β and it ran the next day under the headline JANITOR'S DAUGHTER LASHES OUT.
Principal Evelyn Marsh called her into the office that afternoon and was kind about it, which was worse than anger. Enrollment was down, she said. Parents were calling. Perhaps Deborah might consider a leave of absence, unpaid, until the hearing was over β for the children's sake.
"My children need me here," Deborah said. "I'm a good teacher, Evelyn. You wrote that in my evaluation last spring."
"I know. I'm sorry."
Deborah took the leave. She told herself it was temporary. She told her father it was a vacation. He looked at her the way he looked at everything that winter β steadily, without flinching β and said, "Baby, you don't have to lie to me. I'm the one in trouble, not you."
The plea offer came on the last night of November, in an envelope Michael O'Connell carried into the kitchen like it might explode.
O'Connell was fifty, Irish, a public defender with a private practice on the side and a reputation for taking cases nobody else wanted and then working them like they were his own children's futures. He had believed Elias from the first interview β Deborah had seen it happen, the precise moment in the holding room when her father said "I was in Room B with those children" and O'Connell's pen stopped moving.
"Frances Doyle called me this afternoon," O'Connell said. He set the envelope on the oilcloth and didn't open it. "She's offering to reduce. Burglary in the second degree. Two years. With good behavior you'd serve fourteen months."