"Thank you, Mr. Krueger. I have nothing further."
Deborah let out a breath she hadn't known she was holding. In the row behind her, Frankie Domino whispered, "That's our boy," and somebody shushed him.
Doyle called the fire marshal next, who established the time of the alarm β 9:23 p.m. β and that the fire had been set deliberately with an accelerant in the storage room. O'Connell asked two questions: whether the marshal could say when the cash box had been taken (he could not), and whether the marshal had found any trace of accelerant on Elias Grant's clothing or cart (he had not). The marshal admitted both.
Then O'Connell called June Park.
She was sixteen, small for her age, wearing a navy dress her mother had clearly pressed that morning, and she walked to the witness stand with the careful steps of someone trying not to trip. O'Connell smiled at her, and she smiled back, a quick nervous flash.
"June," O'Connell said, "do you play an instrument?"
"Yes, sir. Violin."
"And on the evening of October sixteenth, where were you?"
"In Room B, sir. The basement rehearsal room at the Majestic. Me and my brother Sam and Eddie Navarro. We were rehearsing for the school assembly. Rosa Delgado β she's the sound assistant β she was helping us with the microphones."
"What time did the rehearsal begin?"
"Seven-thirty, sir."
"Was anyone else in Room B with you that evening?"
"Mr. Grant, sir. He came down at a quarter to nine. He'd heard us from the hallway, he said, and Sam was having trouble with his breathing on the bridge of 'Blue Bossa,' and Mr. Grant β he used to be a trumpet player, sir β he stayed and coached us."
Deborah watched the jury β there was no jury, this was a hearing, just Judge Lang, but Deborah watched her anyway β and saw the judge writing steadily.
"June," O'Connell said, "do you remember hearing church bells that evening?"
"Yes, sir. St. Stanislaus, across the street. You can hear them in the basement when the vents are open. They rang at nine o'clock. Rosa had the tape recorder running and you can hear them on the tape."
"And after the bells?"
"Mr. Grant was still with us, sir. He was showing Sam how to breathe through the phrase. He said β" June stopped, and her voice wobbled, and she steadied it. "He said, 'The horn can wait, son. Your lungs can't.'"
"Was Mr. Grant still in Room B at twenty past nine?"
"Yes, sir."
"Did he leave the room at any point between a quarter to nine and the time you heard the fire alarm?"
"No, sir. He never left."
O'Connell turned to the judge. "Your Honor, the defense proffers the testimony of Rosa Delgado regarding a reel-to-reel tape recording made in Room B that evening, and moves to admit the tape itself."
Doyle was on her feet. "Objection, Your Honor. Authentication. We have no foundation that this tape is what counsel claims it is, or that it hasn't been altered."
"Then let's lay the foundation," Judge Lang said. "Call your witness, Mr. O'Connell."
Rosa Delgado took the stand β twenty-eight, composed, her hands folded in her lap. She described the recorder, a two-track machine she had set up to capture the rehearsal for the students. She described starting the reels at a quarter past seven and letting them run. She described removing the reels afterward, labeling them in her own hand, and keeping them at her home until she delivered them, sealed, to Mr. O'Connell's office.
"And the tape has been in your custody or counsel's custody continuously since then?" O'Connell asked.
"Yes, sir."
Doyle cross-examined briefly β could anyone else have handled the reels, had Rosa ever left the locker unlocked β and Rosa answered each question without hesitation. When Doyle sat down, Judge Lang removed her glasses and cleaned them, a gesture Deborah would remember for years.
"The court will hear the tape," Judge Lang said. "Tomorrow morning, nine o'clock. We are adjourned."
The gavel came down, and the courtroom exhaled all at once, and Deborah turned to her father and saw that his eyes were wet, and he was smiling.
In the back row, Detective Anne Kowalski closed her notebook and stood. She was the one who had taken Elias in that October night β gently, apologizing as she read him his rights β and Deborah had never known what to make of her, until now, when Kowalski caught Deborah's eye across the crowded room and gave her the smallest of nods, the kind one professional gives another when the work is finally going right.
In the corridor outside, the crowd funneled toward the elevators, reporters calling questions O'Connell waved off with practiced ease. Deborah had her father's arm again, and they were nearly to the doors when she saw him.
Gerald Fenn stood by the water fountain at the far end of the corridor, alone, his briefcase hanging from one hand as if he had forgotten it was there. He was staring at the courtroom doors. His face had gone the color of old paper.
A younger man in a suit β his lawyer, Deborah supposed β said something to him, low and urgent. Fenn didn't answer. He just stood there, very still, listening to the sound of his own future arriving.
Β
The courtroom was too warm.
That was the first thing Elias Grant noticed when the bailiff led him in on the second morning β the radiators hissing along the north wall like the old steam pipes at the Majestic, the smell of wet wool rising off the gallery where people had shaken the December rain from their coats, and the low, tired murmur of a roomful of strangers waiting to find out what kind of man he was. He sat down beside Michael O'Connell and folded his hands on the table in front of him, the way Deborah had told him to, and tried not to look at the empty chair behind the prosecution table where Frances Doyle would sit.
"You all right?" O'Connell asked. He was a big man, red in the face from the cold walk over, with ink on his cuffs and the habit of tapping his pen twice before he spoke, as if knocking before entering his own sentences.
"I'm sitting down," Elias said. "That's about the size of it."
"Tape day," O'Connell said. "You just sit. You listen. Let the machine do the talking."