Beata put the kettle on, because Beata believed a kettle was the correct response to any catastrophe up to and including the end of the world, and then she stood with her hands folded in her apron and cried without making a sound, the tears going down her round face in straight lines. She had known Lucia. Everyone in that kitchen had known Lucia. She had been dead two years, and I had been there three, and still her name lived in the kitchen like a fourth stove burner, always warm. Lucia liked her coffee too sweet. Lucia stole plums off the tree and ate them over the sink. The dead girl was more present in that house than most of the living.
My hands were still shaking. I put them under my arms and then I put them on my belly, which was where they went now without asking me, seven months of him growing under my ribs, my son, who kicked once, hard, as if he objected to the whole afternoon. I was thinking about the suitcase. I was thinking about the weight of it coming down the attic stairs in my arms, metal-heavy, wrong-heavy, and about Gianna's face at the bottom of the hall — not surprised. That was the thing I could not put down. Startled, yes. Horrified, yes. But not surprised. She had known that suitcase the way you know a face. She had known it on sight, in one second, across a hall, and whatever lived inside it had put that scream in her throat before her manners could stop it.
And I was thinking, God forgive me, about Marco.
Marco, who had been dead eight months. Marco, who used to carry things for this family and not look inside them, because that was the whole of his pride, the religion of him. I carry it, Sofia. I don't open it. A man who opens what he carries is a thief with clean hands. He would say it and laugh and kiss the top of my head. Standing in that kitchen with the gates barred and my phone in a fruit basket, I understood with a clarity that felt like falling that if Lucia Castellano had needed something carried, she would have carried it to exactly one man in the world.
I did not know, yet, that I was right. I only knew my mouth was dry and my baby was restless and that when the study door opened and Tommy said my name — just that, "Sofia," from the doorway, not unkindly — every face in the kitchen turned to me with an expression I hope never to be looked at with again, which was pity mixed with relief that it was my name and not theirs.
I walked the length of the hall with my hand trailing the wall like a child. The suitcase was on the rug in front of Adrian's desk, and it looked smaller in that room than it had felt in my arms, which is a trick heavy things play. It was a good suitcase, old, the leather darkened at the corners, Lucia's initials tooled into the flap in gold that had gone dull. L.C. She had never married. There had been talk, once, Beata said, of a boy in Boston, but the talk had come to nothing, and then the lake house had come to everything.
Adrian stood behind his desk. He had taken off his jacket. His sleeves were rolled to the forearm, one turn, precise, and he was looking at the suitcase the way a man looks at a wire he is deciding whether to cut. Antonia was in the leather chair by the fire with her cane across her knees like a rifle. She was seventy years old and straight as a fence post and she had not spoken one word since her grandson carried her dead daughter's luggage into the room. Tommy stood by the door. He closed it behind me.
"Sit down," Adrian said.
I sat. There was a chair placed for me, not the hard one by the door where tradesmen sat, but a real chair, near the desk, and I understood that this was a courtesy with a hook in it: I was being treated as a person whose words mattered, which in that house meant I was being treated as evidence.
"You carried it down from the attic," Adrian said. "Tell me the afternoon. All of it, in order. Don't arrange it for me. Just tell it the way it happened."