After they left, Gwen said, "I liked Ellie. I liked having people here. It felt normal."
"It was normal," I said. "And we can do it again, whenever you like."
She nodded, and I knew she meant it. The house was becoming a home, not just a place to live, but a place where friends came and where laughter happened, and where the past was not the only thing that lived there.
In August, a letter arrived from my mother that was different from the others. It was longer, and it was more personal. She wrote about her own childhood, about the way she had been raised, about the fear she had carried that if she did not control everything, everything would fall apart. She did not offer it as an excuse. She offered it as an explanation, and she said she was trying to understand herself, and that she was seeing a counsellor of her own, and that she knew she had a long way to go. She wrote that she missed me, and that she missed the family we had once been, and that she hoped, one day, we might be able to sit in the same room without pain.
I read it twice. Then I showed it to Gwen, because it concerned her too, and because I had promised her that I would not keep secrets from her any more, not about my family, not about anything.
"What do you think?" I asked her.
"I think she's trying," Gwen said. "I think it's real. But trying isn't the same as making it right, and I'm not ready to sit in a room with her yet. Maybe one day. Not now."
"Then not now," I said. "I'll write back and tell her that. I'll tell her I read it, and I appreciate her honesty, and that the door isn't closed for ever, but it's not open yet either."
She nodded. "That's fair."
I wrote the letter that evening, and I kept it short and honest, and I posted it the next morning. My mother wrote back a week later, thanking me for replying, and saying she understood, and that she would keep writing, and keep repaying, and keep working on herself, whether or not we ever met again. I believed her. I did not forgive her, not yet, and I did not pretend to. But I believed she was trying, and that was more than I had believed in the first weeks after I came home.
Paige's repayments continued, too. She had moved to a smaller flat, and she was working longer hours, and Daniel Reed told me she had asked him, quietly, whether Gwen would ever want to hear from her. Daniel had told her what I had told him to tell her, that Gwen would decide in her own time, and that no one would rush her. Paige had accepted that, and she had not asked again. I thought about her sometimes, my sister, working in a warehouse, living in a small flat, paying back money she had spent on things she did not need, and I felt a complicated mixture of anger and pity. I was angry at what she had done, and I would be angry for a long time. But I was also glad she was working, and glad she was facing what she had done, instead of running from it. That was the best I could say, and it was honest.
Autumn came, and Gwen's teaching settled into a rhythm. She was still part-time, two days a week, and she was firm about that. She had been offered more hours, and she had said no, not yet, and the school had respected it. She had a classroom of her own now, a small, bright room with posters on the walls and a reading corner with cushions, and she had made it hers, with plants on the windowsill and a jar of pencils that the children were allowed to borrow. I visited once, on a day when she had invited me to come and see where she worked, and I stood at the back of the room while she read a story to a circle of children, her voice warm and animated, the children leaning in, completely absorbed. When she finished, a little boy raised his hand and asked, "Will you read another one tomorrow?" and she said, "I will, if you promise to listen just as well," and he promised, solemnly, and the whole class laughed.
On the way home, she said, "That was the best day I've had in a long time. Not because it was perfect, but because it was mine. I chose it. I built it. Nobody gave it to me, and nobody can take it away."