Luxury Hotel Manager Ordered a Woman Out of the Marble Lobby — Then the Attorney Revealed She Owned the Entire Property

Chapter 10

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The trainee classification was simpler to prove and harder to hear about. The reviewers spoke to nine housekeepers who had been labeled trainees for nine months, and each of them told a version of the same story: they had been hired, told they were trainees, paid three dollars and fifty cents an hour below the scale rate, and assigned the same number of rooms, on the same shifts, as the staff who were paid the full rate. One of them, a woman named Marta, who had previously cleaned hotel rooms in another city, said she had asked, in her third month, when her training would end, and had been told that training ended when her supervisor decided she was ready, and that her supervisor had not yet decided. She had asked again in her sixth month, and had been told the same thing. She had stopped asking in her eighth month, because she had a child to support and because asking had begun to feel like complaining, and because complaining, in that hotel, had consequences that everyone could see. Another, a young man who had come to San Diego from Arizona, said he had believed, for the first months, that the trainee rate was normal, and that he had only learned otherwise when a colleague, in the locker room, had shown him a pay stub with the scale rate on it, and that he had felt, in that moment, something he could not quite name, which was not anger, exactly, but the recognition that he had been treated as less than a worker while doing the work of a worker. The reviewers calculated the underpayment across the nine housekeepers and the others whose records matched, and the total was substantial, and it was, Ramona noted, the kind of sum that could be repaid, which mattered, because a finding that could be repaid was a finding that could be fixed, and a finding that could be fixed was a finding that the ownership group could act on without waiting for a court.

While the review went on, Emma Grey ran the hotel, and she ran it in a way that was itself a kind of evidence. She did not hold rallies or make speeches. She walked the back of the house every morning, the way Ramona had walked it on the first Monday, and she asked the same questions Ramona had asked, and she wrote down the answers in a notebook of her own. She restored the team-lift equipment to every floor, and she had the laundry press guard repaired, and she had the unlabeled spray bottles removed from the carts and replaced with labeled ones, and she did these things without announcing them, so that the staff discovered them the way they had discovered the problems: by encountering them in the course of their work. She told the department heads that schedules would be posted a week earlier than before, and that any schedule change after a formal complaint would need her approval, and that complaints would henceforth be taken in writing, with a tracking number, through a channel outside direct management. A few managers grumbled. Most did not. One department head, who had been one of the two who received bonuses from the reserve, asked Emma Grey, in private, whether the bonuses would be investigated, and Emma Grey said that everything would be investigated, and that he would have his own opportunity to respond, and that he should preserve his records. He did, and the reviewers later found his records helpful, in the way that records kept by a worried man often are: complete, dated, and more honest than the account he gave alongside them.

Ramona watched all of this from the conference room, and she was careful not to confuse Emma Grey's interim management with the review itself. The review was hers. The management was Emma's. The distinction mattered, because a review that became management would lose its independence, and an auditor who became a manager would lose the trust of the people she was auditing. She kept to her interviews, and her records, and her notebook, and she let Emma Grey run the hotel, and she noted, in her working papers, that the hotel was already changing, in small, practical ways, before the report had been written. She did not treat that as a conclusion. She treated it as a fact, and she wrote it down, and she moved on to the next interview, because there were still people she had not heard from, and because a review that stopped early would be a review that had chosen its ending before it had finished its work.

News in the same category

Luxury Hotel Manager Ordered a Woman Out of the Marble Lobby — Then the Attorney Revealed She Owned the Entire Property

45 Part