Chef Roland Beck came back to the conference room in the third week, this time without being asked, and he brought with him a stack of banquet staffing sheets that he had kept in his office, in a drawer that no one else opened. He laid them out on the table and walked the reviewers through them, night by night, showing how the kitchen had been staffed on evenings when the banquet hall was full, and how, on more than one occasion, the staffing had fallen short by two or three people, and how the banquet captain had covered the gap by moving servers from one station to another, and how the guests had never noticed, because the staff had worked harder, and because that was what staff did. Beck said he had raised the staffing question with Rowe twice, once in person and once in writing, and that the written note had never been answered, and that the in-person conversation had ended with Rowe saying that the kitchen would manage, and that managing was what kitchens did. Beck said he had stopped raising it after that, not because he agreed, but because he had a kitchen to run, and because a chef who argued with a general manager every week would soon be a chef without a kitchen. He said he regretted stopping, and that the regret had grown as the review went on, and that he was speaking now because the review had made it possible to speak without immediately wondering what it would cost. Ramona thanked him, and she wrote down the staffing sheets, and she noted that Beck's account, like Marco's and Janet's, was the account of someone who had kept a record because he had not trusted the official one, and that a hotel where the honest records were kept in lockers and drawers, rather than in files, was a hotel whose filing system had failed before its people had.
The housekeeping supervisor, a woman named Isabel who had held the post for six years, gave a different kind of account, and Ramona listened to it with particular care, because supervisors are the people a review most needs to hear from and most often fails to hear honestly. Isabel said she had assigned the rooms, and set the schedules, and handled the complaints that came to her, and that she had done her best with the staff she had and the hours she was given. She said the trainee classifications had come from above, and that she had questioned them once, early on, and had been told that the classification was a corporate matter, and that she should not worry about it. She said the injury logs had not been hers to write, and that she had reported injuries as she had seen them, and that what happened to a report after it left her desk was not something she had controlled. She said the schedule cuts had been hers, in some cases, and that she had cut hours when the hotel was slow, and that she could show the occupancy figures for those weeks, and that she was sorry if anyone had read a cut as a punishment when it had been a business decision. The reviewers checked the occupancy figures, and in two cases Isabel was right, and in three cases she was not, because the hotel had not been slow in those weeks, and because the cuts had followed, within days, a disagreement or a complaint. Isabel, when shown this, did not argue. She looked at the figures for a long time, and then she said that she had not known, or had not let herself know, and that she would accept whatever the review concluded about her, and that she wanted, if she stayed, to do the job differently. Ramona wrote this down, and she marked it, in her own mind, as the most hopeful thing she had heard in the review so far, because a supervisor who could look at a record and change her mind was a supervisor who could be retrained, and because the review would need to distinguish, carefully, between the people who had built the system and the people who had merely worked inside it.