The two department heads who had received bonuses from the reserve were interviewed separately, and at length, and their interviews were among the longest in the review, because they had the most to explain and the least room to explain it in. One of them, the head of the front office, said the bonuses had been for performance, and when asked what performance, he described a quarter in which guest satisfaction scores had risen, and the reviewers checked the scores, and they had risen, slightly, and they noted that, because a fact that helps a person under review is still a fact, and because a review that ignored it would not be fair. The same man, when asked about the informal chats that had replaced written complaints, said he had believed he was helping, by resolving things quickly, and that he had not understood that a quick resolution without a record was a resolution that could not be checked, and that he had learned that now, and that he wished he had learned it sooner. The other, the head of banquets, said less, and what he said was less helpful, and the reviewers noted that too, without comment, because a review does not punish silence, and because the records would speak where he would not. Both men were told, as everyone was told, that they would have an opportunity to respond to the report before it was finalized, and that their responses would be included, and that the ownership group would decide, individually, what would happen to each of them. Neither man looked reassured by this, and Ramona understood why. A process that is fair is not necessarily a process that is comfortable, and the difference between the two is the reason processes exist.
In the fourth week, Mitchell Rowe returned for his interview, accompanied by his own lawyer, a man in a grey suit who carried a thin briefcase and who spoke only to clarify questions and to remind Rowe, at intervals, that he could take his time. Rowe arrived punctually, and he was composed, and he had plainly prepared. He began by saying that he had run the Paloma Court for six years, that he had raised its occupancy and its guest satisfaction scores, and that he had done so in a difficult market, with a historic building that needed constant attention, and with a staff that turned over faster than he could replace it. He said the hotel's image was his responsibility, and that he had taken that responsibility seriously, and that if he had sometimes been blunt, it was because the work required bluntness, and because guests noticed everything, and because a hotel that did not notice itself would soon be noticed by its competitors. Ramona listened, and she did not interrupt, and she wrote down what he said, because a review that does not listen to the person under review has already decided, and because Rowe, whatever else he had done, was entitled to be heard in full.
He blamed, in turn, the department heads, the staffing shortages, the corporate paperwork, and the former owners. The department heads, he said, had been responsible for schedules and assignments, and if schedules had been cut unfairly, that was a matter for them to answer. The staffing shortages, he said, had forced difficult choices, and if trainees had been kept on longer than they should have been, that was because the hotel could not afford to lose them and could not afford to pay them more. The corporate paperwork, he said, had made the service-charge accounting confusing, and if the reserve had been used for purposes that looked improper, that was because the rules governing it had never been made clear to him. The former owners, he said, had left him a building with deferred problems and a staff with low morale, and he had done his best with what he had inherited. He said all of this calmly, and some of it, the reviewers later found, held up. The occupancy figures did show a difficult market. The staffing shortages were real, and they were documented in hiring records that predated Rowe's tenure. The guest satisfaction scores had indeed risen, slightly, in his second year. Ramona marked these points, and she told her team to give Rowe credit where the records supported him, because a report that denied a man his genuine achievements would be a report that no one would trust about his failures.