The lobby video, obtained from the hotel's own security system, confirmed both accounts, and it confirmed something else as well: the order of events. Ramona arrived, Bianca greeted her, the letter was shown, Bianca reached for the telephone, Rowe intervened, the ownership office was not called from the desk, the removal was ordered, Simon questioned it, Simon called the ownership office himself. The video had no sound, but it did not need sound, because the gestures were plain, and because Bianca's and Simon's accounts, given separately, matched it in every particular. Felix Anders preserved the video with the rest of the records, and the reviewers noted, in their working papers, that the lobby incident, which had begun the review, was now the least contested fact in it. Everything else would be harder, because everything else involved money, and money, unlike a lobby, can be explained in many ways.
The money, when the reviewers followed it, led to the Service Excellence Reserve. The reserve was a real account, with real statements, and the statements showed what Marco's ledger had said they would show: banquet service charges coming in at twenty-two percent, eight percent going to staff, and the remainder accumulating in the reserve, from which Rowe had paid for a leased luxury car, for country-club dues, and for bonuses to two department heads. The two department heads were interviewed, separately, and their accounts diverged in instructive ways. One said the bonuses were for performance, and could not say what performance, specifically, they had rewarded. The other said the bonuses were for loyalty, and then corrected himself, and said they were for handling difficult situations quietly, and then stopped, as if he had heard himself. The reviewers did not press him. They did not need to. The bank records, the ledger, and the contracts, laid side by side, told the story without anyone's help: guests had been billed a charge they reasonably believed was a gratuity, staff had received less than half of it, and the difference had been spent on the comfort and the allies of the man who controlled it. Ramona wrote in her notebook that this was the finding that would be hardest for the ownership group to read, not because it was the largest sum, but because it was the clearest betrayal of trust: a guest had shaken a banquet captain's hand and hoped the staff had been taken care of, and the staff had not been, and the money had gone to a car.
The tip pool, when the reviewers took it apart, turned out to be a quieter version of the same story. Housekeeping tips at the Paloma Court were pooled, which was not in itself unusual, and redistributed by a system of points, which was not in itself improper. What made it improper was the way the points were assigned, and the way they were adjusted after the fact. Front-desk and concierge staff, who were already the most visible and the best paid among the hourly workers, received points at a rate that reflected their visibility rather than their work, while housekeepers, who cleaned the rooms where the tips were actually left, received points at a rate that reflected, as one housekeeper put it, the fact that nobody saw them do it. The adjustments were the worse part. In a dozen instances across the payroll screenshots and the hotel's own records, the pool was calculated, and then recalculated by hand, with points moved from housekeeping to the front desk, and with no written explanation for the change. Janet Pryce, when asked about one such adjustment, said she had been told to make it because the front desk had had a difficult week, and that she had made it, and that she had not understood, then, that a difficult week at the desk was not a reason to take money from the people who had cleaned the rooms. She said this without self-pity, and Ramona, who had heard many payroll clerks explain many adjustments in many hotels, recognized the particular tone of someone who had done something she now regretted and who was determined not to do it again.