Luxury Hotel Manager Ordered a Woman Out of the Marble Lobby — Then the Attorney Revealed She Owned the Entire Property

Chapter 15

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The report's conclusions were plain, and they were stated in the order of their seriousness. Mitchell Rowe had repeatedly violated workplace-conduct policy, by criticizing staff in public, in front of guests, on occasions that the reviewers documented with dates, witnesses, and, in one case, the lobby video. He had used schedules and assignments inconsistently after personal conflicts, cutting hours and moving staff out of visible posts in ways that the schedules themselves showed, and that could not be explained by occupancy or by business need in the cases cited. He had blocked formal records for some complaints, diverting them into informal chats that left no trace, so that the complaint file was thin in exactly the places where the staff's accounts were thick. He had misclassified trainees, keeping new housekeepers at three dollars and fifty cents an hour below scale for nine months while they carried full workloads. He had diverted banquet service charges, so that only eight percent of a twenty-two percent charge reached staff, and the remainder went to a reserve he controlled, which paid for his car, his club dues, and bonuses to two department heads. He had manipulated the tip pool, so that housekeepers' shares were reduced by points and by hand adjustments that favored front-desk and concierge staff. And he had falsified injury records, so that fourteen injuries were recorded as non-work-related, or as declined treatment, or moved to a different date, when the nurse's notes and the safety consultant's findings showed otherwise.

The report also said what Rowe had done well, and it said it without grudging. It said he had raised occupancy in a difficult market, and that guest satisfaction scores had risen in his second year, and that he had kept a historic building running through years when other hotels in the city had closed. It said that staffing shortages were real, and that some schedule decisions had been legitimate business decisions, and it named the cases where the reviewers had found a legitimate explanation, so that the ownership group could see that the reviewers had looked for exoneration as carefully as they had looked for fault. And it said, plainly, which rumors had not been supported: no cash taken from the safe, no physical violence, no supplier kickbacks, no pocketed banquet deposits. Ramona insisted on this section, even though one of her reviewers argued that it would soften the report, because she believed the opposite: that a report which cleared a man of what he did not do was a report that could be believed about what he did do, and that the staff, who would read the report's conclusions, deserved to know that the review had not simply believed everything it had been told.

Before the report was finalized, Rowe and the two department heads were given an opportunity to respond, and their responses were included, in full, as an appendix, so that anyone who read the report would read the defense alongside the findings. Rowe's response was long, and it repeated his explanations about department heads and shortages and paperwork and former owners, and it added a new argument, which was that the service-charge reserve had been established before his tenure, and that he had inherited its rules. The reviewers checked this, and they found that the reserve had indeed existed before Rowe, but that its use had changed under him, and that the car and the club dues and the bonuses had all begun during his tenure, and they noted this, fairly, in a footnote, so that Rowe's point was recorded and its limits were visible. One department head's response was apologetic, and the other was brief, and both were included without comment, because a report does not argue with its appendix. It lets the appendix speak, and it lets the reader judge.

The report was delivered to the ownership group on a Tuesday morning, in a bound copy and in a digital file, and Emma Grey read it first, and then Felix Anders, and then the ownership group's board, and the room where they read it was quiet, in the way that rooms are quiet when people are reading something that will require them to act. Ramona was not in the room. She had delivered the report, and she had answered questions about its methods, and then she had left, because the report was no longer hers. It belonged to the people who would have to decide what to do with it, and she had learned, over eleven hotels, that an auditor who lingered to lobby for her own conclusions would soon be mistaken for an advocate, and that an advocate's report is worth less than an auditor's. She walked out of the ownership group's office and into the San Diego afternoon, and she did not know what the decision would be, and she did not try to guess, and she went home and slept, for the first time in weeks, without dreaming about ledgers.

News in the same category

Luxury Hotel Manager Ordered a Woman Out of the Marble Lobby — Then the Attorney Revealed She Owned the Entire Property

45 Part