But some of his explanations were weak, and some contradicted the records, and the contradictions were sharpest where the records were clearest. When the reviewers compared his account of the lobby incident with the lobby video, the video did not support him. He had said he had offered to verify Ramona's business, and the video showed him refusing Bianca's offer to call. He had said he had acted to protect guests, and the video showed a woman who had threatened no one and who had shown her papers. When the reviewers compared his account of the service-charge reserve with Marco's ledger and the bank statements, the ledger did not support him. He had said the reserve was for the good of the hotel, and the statements showed a leased car and club dues. He had said the rules had never been made clear, and the contracts showed, in plain language, a twenty-two percent charge that guests would reasonably read as a gratuity, and payroll records showed eight percent reaching staff. When the reviewers compared his account of the injury logs with the nurse's private notes and the consultant's findings, the notes did not support him. He had said injuries were recorded accurately, and fourteen injuries had been rewritten, all in the same direction, toward making the hotel look safer than it was. Rowe, confronted with each of these, in turn, and with time to answer, said that he had relied on others, and that he had not personally altered a log or moved a decimal, and that he had trusted his department heads to handle details. The reviewers wrote this down, too, because it was true as far as it went, and because it did not go far enough: a general manager who controls a reserve account, and who signs the schedules, and who tells a security officer to remove a woman from his lobby, is not a man who merely relies on others. He is a man who decides, and who must answer for his decisions.
His lawyer asked, at the end of the interview, whether the review would consider Rowe's years of service and his record of raising occupancy, and Ramona said it would, and that the report would say so, and that the report would also say what the records showed, and that the two things would stand side by side, because that was what fairness required. Rowe thanked her, without warmth, and left with his lawyer, and the conference room was quiet after they had gone, in the way that rooms are quiet after a difficult conversation, with the air still holding the shape of it. Ramona sat for a while, and then she opened her notebook, and she wrote down the interview in order, and she marked, in the margin, the points where Rowe's account had held and the points where it had not, and she thought about how rarely, in her work, a person was entirely one thing or the other, and about how the report would have to hold both things at once, without letting one excuse the other.
The review also had to deal with rumors, and there were many of them, because a hotel is a small town with corridors, and because a review, once it begins, loosens tongues that have been tight for years. Ramona treated rumors the way she treated everything else: she wrote them down, she checked them, and she marked them, plainly, as supported or unsupported, and she did not let an unsupported rumor into the report as if it were a finding. There were four rumors about Rowe that the staff repeated most often, and the review examined each of them, and the results were instructive, because they showed that a man could be guilty of serious misconduct and still not be guilty of everything people said about him.
The first rumor was that Rowe had taken cash from the hotel safe. Two staff members said they had heard it, and one said he had seen Rowe at the safe late at night, but no one could say how much, or when, or what had happened to the money afterward, and the safe records, which Felix Anders helped preserve, showed no discrepancies, and the cash-handling logs balanced, week after week, across the entire period of the review. The reviewers marked the rumor unsupported, and Ramona wrote, in her working papers, that a review that reported an unproved theft alongside a proved diversion would damage its own credibility, and that credibility was the only currency a review had.
The second rumor was that Rowe had been physically violent with a member of staff. One housekeeper said she had heard shouting from the housekeeping office, and another said a supervisor had once come out of a meeting with Rowe looking shaken, but no one described a blow, or a shove, or a threat of physical harm, and the people who had worked most closely with Rowe said he had never touched anyone in anger, and that his weapon, if it could be called that, had been his voice, and his control of schedules, and his ability to make a person feel small in front of others. The reviewers marked the rumor unsupported as a claim of physical violence, and they recorded, separately, that public criticism and humiliation were themselves serious, and that they did not need to be exaggerated into something else in order to matter.