iron swollen with rust, the edges sealed as if the hatch had grown into the floor, and he thought about how three years of cold running water could do that, could seal iron to stone, and how patient water was, and how patient rust was, and how the two of them together had done what no lock could do, which was to make the hatch a part of the floor itself. He put his hands into the water, and the water was so cold it made his knuckles ache, and he felt along the edges with his fingers, and he found the seam, thin as a hair, where the hatch met the stone, and he worked the tip of the chisel into the seam, and he tapped it, and the rust cracked, and a thin line of red came away, and the water took it, and he worked the chisel along the seam, an inch at a time, and the seam opened, a little, and then a little more, and still the hatch did not move, because the lock held it, and the lock was the worst of it. He sat back, and he wiped his hands on his trousers, and he looked at the lock, and the lock was the worst of it, a small iron padlock, rusted solid, the keyhole choked with rust, and he knew that no key in the world would turn in that lock now, and that he would have to break it, or cut it, or work it loose with oil and patience, and he had patience, and he had oil, and he had the rest of the night.
He poured oil into the keyhole, and around the hasp, and around the ring, and he waited, and while he waited, he thought about Rose, and about the key, and about where the key had gone, and he thought that she must have kept it, or thrown it into the creek, or taken it with her, and that it did not matter now, because the key was gone, and the lock would have to be broken, and the breaking of it would be his work, and the opening of it would be his work, and the reading of whatever was inside would be his work, and he was ready for the work, even if he was not ready for the truth.
He thought about the last morning. He had woken before the light, the way he always did, and she had already been up, and the trunk was by the door, packed neat, with her good dress folded on top, the gray one with the white collar, and she had been standing at the kitchen table, with her hands flat on the wood, and she had been coughing, a cough that would not stop, a cough that shook her whole body, and he had gone to her, and he had put his hand on her back, and she had said, "It is nothing, Hiram. It is only the cold air," and he had believed her, or pretended to, because he did not know what else to do, and because she had always been the strong one, and because the idea that she was sick, truly sick, was a thing he could not hold in his head. She had held Lucy for a long time at the table, longer than usual, and she had braided Lucy's hair, three strands, and tied the ribbon, and she had said, "There. Now you look like my girl," and she had kissed Lucy's forehead, and she had looked at him, and she had said, "Take care of her, Hiram," and he had said, "I will," and she had said, "Promise me," and he had said, "I promise," and then she had picked up the trunk, and she had gone out to the wagon, and he had driven her to town, and she had gotten down at the road, and she had said, "Goodbye, Hiram," and he had said, "Goodbye, Rose," and she had walked away, down the road, with the trunk, and he had watched her go, and he had not followed her, and he had not asked her where she was going, and he had not asked her why, and he had driven home, and Lucy had stood in the yard and watched the road for a long time, and then she had come inside, and she had not cried, and she had not asked where her mother had gone, and he had not told her, because there was nothing to tell.