He thought about the town, too, and about what the town had said about him for three years. The town had said that Rose had run off, because that was the simplest story, and the town liked simple stories, and Hiram had never corrected it, because correcting it would have meant telling the town that his wife had been sick, and that she had gone away to die where their daughter would not have to watch, and that was not the town's business, and it was not a story he had been ready to tell. The town had said that he ought to marry again, because a man with a little girl needed a wife, and a house needed a woman, and the town had said it kindly, the way towns say such things, and Odessa had been the town's answer, because she was kind, and because she was alone, and because she was there, and Hiram had let the town's answer become his answer, and he had almost asked her, and now he was riding to town to unsay it, and he knew the town would talk about that, too, and he did not care, because the town's talk was not his life, and his life was the house, and the child, and the truth, and those were enough.
He thought about Rose on that road, too, because he had ridden it with her once, years ago, when Lucy was a baby, and Rose had ridden beside him with the baby wrapped against her chest, and the creek had been high that spring, and the cottonwoods had been green, and Rose had laughed at something he had said, and he could not remember now what it was, only the sound of it, and the way the light had been on her face, and he thought about how a man could lose a wife and keep the sound of her laugh, and how he had spent three years trying to fill the place where she had been with work, and with silence, and with a new wife he did not love, and how none of it had filled it, and how the only thing that had filled any of it was the truth, told plainly to his daughter, and he thought about that as he rode, and the road went on, and the creek went on beside it.
He owed her thanks. She had been kind to Lucy. She had brought soup to the house when Lucy was sick with a cold in the winter. She had mended Lucy's dress when the seam tore. She had sat with Lucy at the church social and taught her a song. She had never once said an unkind word about Rose, and she had never once asked him to stop speaking of Rose, and that was a kindness, and he knew it, and he would tell her so. He owed her plainness. He owed her the truth, spoken to her face, in private, before the town could make a story of it. He did not owe her a marriage. He did not owe her his name, or his house, or his daughter's childhood, and he would not give her those things out of gratitude, because gratitude was not love, and a marriage built on gratitude would be a poor house for them all to live in, and he knew that now, and he had not known it a week ago, and the knowing of it had cost him a week of hard thinking, and it was worth it.
Ember Falls came into view around the bend, the white houses and the church steeple and the store and the boarding house on the corner, and Hiram rode down the main street, and he nodded to the storekeeper, and he nodded to the blacksmith, and he tied his horse at the rail in front of the boarding house, and he stood for a moment on the sidewalk and looked up at the house.