take it away, not ever. And I went to bed happy, and I dreamed of Mama, and in the dream she was sitting by the springhouse, and the water was running cold and clear over the stones, and she was smiling, and she was not sick anymore, and I was not afraid. When I woke up in the morning, the sun was coming through the window, and my primer was on the shelf by my bed, and I knew the words of Mama's poem still, every one of them, and I said them once more to myself, very quiet, before I got up, because they were mine to keep.
The letter from Denver came on a Tuesday, in the middle of October. The mail rider brought it up the road from Ember Falls, and he left it on the fence post by the gate, the way he always did, and I found it when I came back from the pasture, and I knew at once what it was, because the handwriting on the envelope was a woman's hand, careful and small, and the postmark said Denver, and my heart went still in my chest, because I had been waiting for this letter all summer, ever since I had written to Rose's sister in Denver, after I had read Rose's letter from the springhouse, and learned that Rose had gone to her sister, and died there. The rider was already gone down the road by the time I saw the envelope, a cloud of dust behind his horse, and I stood at the gate for a long moment with the letter in my hand, and I did not open it there, in the road, because some things should not be read standing in the dust. I carried it up to the house, slow, the way a man walks when he is carrying something heavy, though the letter weighed nothing at all, and I thought about the three years since Rose had left, and about the summer since I had found her letters, and about how long I had waited to know where she lay, and about how the knowing was finally here, in my hand, in an envelope with a woman's careful handwriting on it.
I had written to her in July, the week after I opened the hatch. I had written plainly, the way a man writes when he does not know how to dress up the truth. I had told her who I was, and that I had found Rose's letters under the water in the springhouse, and that I knew now that Rose had been sick, and that she had come to Denver to die with her sister, and I had asked her, if it was not too much to ask, to tell me where Rose was buried, so that I could tell Lucy one day, when Lucy was old enough to ask. I had not expected an answer quickly. Denver was far, and the mail was slow, and a woman who had lost her sister might not want to write to a stranger. But I had written it anyway, because it was the right thing to do, and because Lucy would ask one day, and I wanted to have an answer for her.
I carried the letter into the house, and I set it on the kitchen table, and I sat down, and I looked at it for a long time before I opened it. The kitchen was quiet. Lucy was at school, and the old hand was out in the pasture, and the house was empty except for me, and the clock ticking on the wall, and the tin box on the mantel, and the letters in the drawer. I thought about Rose, and about the spring of 1889, when she had died in Denver and I had not known, and about how I had gone on living here, not knowing, and about how the not knowing had been its own kind of grief, and I thought about how this letter would end it, and how the ending of it would be a grief of its own.
I opened the letter with my knife, careful, so as not to tear the paper inside, and I unfolded it, and I read it, slow, the way I read everything that matters.
It began plainly. The sister wrote that she was glad to hear from me, and that she had wondered for three years whether I would ever write, and that she had kept Rose's letters, and her things, and that she had waited to hear from me. She wrote that Rose had come to her in the autumn of 1888, thin and coughing, with a small bag and nothing else, and that she had stayed through the