and about how it would be a living thing, growing here, for Rose, and about how a living thing was a better marker than a stone, because a stone only said that someone was gone, and a rosebush said that someone was remembered.
Lucy came home from school as I was finishing, and she came down the road with her lunch pail in her hand, and her primer under her arm, and she saw me standing by the springhouse, and she saw the rosebush, and she came running, and she said, "Papa, what is that?"
"It is a rosebush, Lucy," I said. "For your mama. I am planting it here, by the springhouse, so there will be something growing here for her."
Lucy looked at it, and she looked at the springhouse, and she looked at me, and she said, "Will it have roses, Papa?"
"It will," I said. "In the spring. Red ones, I hope. Your mama liked red roses."
Lucy knelt down beside the rosebush, and she touched one of the bare branches, very gently, with one finger, and she said, "Hello, Mama's rosebush. Grow big, and grow strong, and I will come and see you every day." And then she stood up, and she took my hand, and we walked back up to the house together, and the sun was going down, and the rosebush stood by the springhouse, small and bare, in the damp earth, with the water running cold and clear beside it, and it was planted, and it was done, and I knew it was right. That night, after Lucy was in bed, I sat by the stove with the envelope on the table beside me, and I thought about the woman in Denver, and about the lilacs on the hill, and about the stone with Rose's name on it, and about the rosebush by the springhouse, and about how the two places were far apart, Denver and Ember Falls, and about how they were joined now, by a letter and a drawing and a rosebush, and by the love of a little girl who had never been to Denver and would never see the lilacs, but who would tend a rosebush here, and think of her mama every day. The next morning I rode to Ember Falls, and I left the envelope at the post office, and I watched the clerk stamp it and put it in the mailbag, and I rode home, and the rosebush was still there by the springhouse, small and bare, and the water was still running cold and clear over the stones, and I knew that some things, once planted, do not need watching to grow.
The first frost came in the last week of October, white on the grass and white on the roof of the springhouse, and I woke before the light did, the way I always did, and I went out to the barn in the cold, and the air was sharp in my lungs, and my breath came out white, and the horses were stamping in their stalls, and I fed them, and I watered them, and I milked the cow, and the milk was warm in the pail, and I carried it back to the house, and I fed the hens, and I scattered corn for them, and I checked the woodpile by the back door, stacked high and dry under the eave, and I checked the cellar door, shut tight against the cold, and I came back to the house with the milk pail in my hand, and the kitchen was warm, because Lucy had already lit the stove, and she was sitting at the table with her primer open, practicing her letters, and the lamp was lit, and the tin box was on the mantel, where it always was, and the house smelled of bread and coffee, and the coffee pot was on the stove, and the bread was rising in the pan by the window, and I set the milk pail down, and I poured myself a cup of coffee, and I thought about how much had changed since the summer, and about how much had stayed the same.
That morning, after breakfast, Lucy went to the drawer where the letters lay, and she opened it, and she took out her mama's letter, the one Rose had written for her, and she brought it to the table, and she sat down, and she unfolded it, careful, along the creases, and she began to read it herself, slow, sounding out the long words, and stopping when she came to one she did not know, and asking