He had thought about that morning a hundred times since, and each time he thought about it, he saw something he had missed. He saw now that she had been thinner than she had been, and that her hands had been cool when she touched his face, and that she had been coughing for months, all winter, and that she had hidden it from him, or tried to, and that she had packed the trunk herself, in the night, while he slept, because she had not wanted him to see her pack it, and because she had not wanted him to stop her. He saw now that she had known she was leaving for good, and that she had said goodbye the way a woman says goodbye when she knows she will not come back, and that he had not understood it then, because he had not wanted to understand it, and because understanding it would have meant doing something, and he had not known what to do. He thought about the winter before she left, the long winter, when the snow had come early and stayed late, and when she had coughed through the nights, and he had lain awake and listened to her, and he had told himself it was only the cold air, and only a winter cough, and that it would pass with the spring, and he had believed it because he needed to believe it, and because the alternative was a thing he could not face. He thought about the way she had laughed, in the early years, before Lucy was born, when the ranch was new and they were young, and the way she had sung in the kitchen while she worked, and the way she had danced with him once, in the yard, to no music at all, and he thought about how the laughing had gone quiet in the last year, and how the singing had stopped, and how he had noticed, and had not said anything, and how the not saying had been a kind of failure, and how he carried that failure with him, the way he carried the silence about her leaving, and the way he would carry it until he knew the whole of the truth, and the box, he hoped, would tell him the whole of the truth, or at least the part of it that Rose had wanted him to know. And he saw now, sitting on the cold stone floor of the springhouse with the oil can in his hand, that she had gone down to this springhouse on that last morning, before he woke, and that she had put something under the water, under the floor, and that she had told Lucy, and only Lucy, and that Lucy had kept it for three years, and that the keeping of it had been a weight on his daughter, and that he had never once seen the weight, and that he was ashamed, and that he was grateful, both at once, and that he did not know which feeling was stronger.
He picked up the hammer, and he tapped the lock, gently at first, and then harder, and the rust flaked off, and the iron rang, dull and low, in the stone room, and he poured more oil, and he tapped again, and he worked the chisel into the edge of the hasp, and he tapped the chisel, and the rust came away in scales, and the water ran cold over the stones, and the lantern light moved on the walls, and he worked, and he did not hurry, because hurrying would break something, and because the thing under the hatch had waited three years, and it could wait one more night, and because he wanted to do it right, the way Rose would have wanted it done, slowly and carefully, with patience. He worked the oil into the joints with his fingers, and the oil was cold, and his fingers were cold, and the water was cold, and the whole of the springhouse was cold, and he did not mind the cold, because the cold was honest, and because the cold was the reason the springhouse existed, and because Rose had loved the cold of it, and had said, more than once, that the springhouse was the best room on the ranch, because it was the only room that never got hot, and never got stuffy, and never