She also required the team to identify gaps in the available evidence rather than filling those gaps with convenient explanations.
It was demanding work, but it helped her regain a sense of perspective.
The encounter on her porch had been unsettling.
It had also reminded her why the review mattered.
An accountability system could not prevent every poor decision. No policy could guarantee that every officer would act wisely under every circumstance.
But a credible system could make it harder for mistakes to be ignored, for patterns to remain hidden, and for authority to become a substitute for justification.
When the meeting ended, Samuel gathered his papers.
"Do you want me to arrange for someone else to handle any review involving Willow Creek?"
Danielle considered the question carefully.
"If the incident becomes part of a formal investigation involving me personally, we should evaluate whether recusal is appropriate. But we shouldn't change the review's procedures simply because I was involved in an encounter."
"Wouldn't that create a conflict?"
"Potentially. That's why we need to distinguish between the department-wide review and any complaint concerning my individual experience. If there's a direct overlap that could compromise impartiality, we address it through the established conflict-of-interest process."
Samuel nodded.
"That makes sense."
"And until then, no one should use my experience to justify a conclusion about the department as a whole. One incident is evidence of one incident. Whether it reflects a broader pattern requires a separate examination."
"I'll make sure the team understands that."
Danielle closed her notebook.
"Thank you."
She walked out of the conference room and returned to her office.
A few minutes later, she received a message from an unknown number.
It was a short email from someone identifying himself as a reporter for the Willow Creek Gazette.
The subject line read: Questions concerning an incident at your residence.
Danielle stared at the screen.
The reporter wrote that the newspaper had received information about a police encounter on her street earlier that day. He asked whether she was willing to comment.
She did not respond immediately.
Instead, she forwarded the message to the office's communications adviser, asking whether any public response was necessary at that stage.
Then she closed the email.
The incident was moving beyond the street where it had occurred.
That was not necessarily a bad thing. Public scrutiny could encourage transparency when handled responsibly.
But she would not allow the possibility of publicity to determine what she did next.
The evidence would come first.
The procedure would come first.
And the truth, whatever it turned out to be, would have to come before anyone's desire to control the story.
Late that afternoon, as Danielle prepared to leave the office, her phone rang again.
This time, the caller was Sergeant Reeves.
"Ms. Brooks, good afternoon. This is Sergeant Daniel Reeves with the Willow Creek Police Department."
"Good afternoon, Sergeant."
"I'm calling to confirm that the department has opened a preliminary review of the encounter this morning. We are preserving the relevant recordings and collecting statements from everyone who responded."
"Thank you for informing me."
"I also want to apologize for the experience you had on your porch. I wasn't present when the interaction began, but based on what I observed, I understand why you're concerned."
Danielle appreciated that he had not attempted to excuse Mitchell's behavior.
"Thank you, Sergeant. I appreciate your professionalism."
"We want to handle this properly. If you decide to submit a formal complaint, the information Officer Grant sent you will explain how to do that."
"I received it."
"Is there anything else you'd like to know at this stage?"
Danielle thought for a moment.
"Yes. Will the department preserve the original dispatch recording and the body-camera footage from all responding officers?"
"Yes."
"Will the review include the original complaint that prompted the response?"
"Yes. We are requesting the complete record."
"And will the department interview the civilian witnesses?"
"We intend to."
"Good. I would appreciate confirmation that those steps have been completed when the preliminary review is finished."
"I can provide that confirmation."
Danielle thanked him, and they ended the call.
For several seconds, she remained seated at her desk.
Reeves had done what a responsible supervisor should do. He had acknowledged the concern, explained the steps being taken, and avoided promising an outcome before the facts were established.
That was encouraging.
But it was only the beginning.
A preliminary review could reveal what happened during one encounter. It could not, by itself, establish whether the department had a larger problem.
To answer that question, investigators would need to examine records, compare incidents, and determine whether similar patterns had appeared before.
And somewhere in the department's files, there might be information that nobody had yet thought to connect.
Danielle switched off her desk lamp and gathered her belongings.
Outside the building, the sky had begun to darken.
She drove home through the evening traffic, passing familiar shops and restaurants as people hurried to finish their errands. The ordinary rhythm of the city seemed almost reassuring.