He picked up the phone and called the records administrator.
"Good morning, Lieutenant," the administrator answered.
"Good morning. I need you to help me trace several archived body-camera files connected to older civilian complaints. I have the case numbers here. One of the archive references appears in the migration log, but the recording isn't linked to the complaint."
There was a short silence.
"I can check that," the administrator replied. "Some of those files were moved during the system conversion. The index didn't always transfer cleanly."
"Could a recording exist in the archive even if the complaint file doesn't show it?"
"Yes. It is possible."
"Could the archive show that a recording existed but no longer retain the actual file?"
"That depends on the retention schedule and whether the original file was preserved."
Harris looked down at his notes.
"Then I need the history, not just the current status. Who accessed the file, when it was moved, whether it was reviewed, and whether it was deleted or marked for retention."
"I understand."
"I also need the applicable retention policy as it existed when the complaint was filed. Please don't make any changes to the records while we're reviewing them."
"Of course."
After ending the call, Harris wrote down the time and summarized the conversation in his investigation log. It was a routine step, but he wanted every request documented. If the inquiry later expanded, no one would have to rely on memories of informal conversations.
At nine o'clock, Ryan Mitchell entered the internal affairs conference room.
He wore his uniform and carried a thin notebook. His expression was controlled, though his jaw tightened when he saw the camera mounted in the corner. Harris had explained in the meeting notice that the interview would be recorded.
"Have a seat, Officer Mitchell."
Mitchell sat down and placed his notebook in front of him.
"Am I being disciplined?" he asked.
"This is a formal administrative inquiry. No final determination has been made."
"About the woman on the porch?"
"About that encounter and several related questions concerning prior complaints."
Mitchell's eyes narrowed slightly.
"Related questions?"
"We are reviewing the circumstances of the encounter, the accuracy of your report, your compliance with department policy, and whether earlier complaints involving similar allegations were handled appropriately."
For a moment, Mitchell said nothing.
Then he leaned back in his chair.
"I followed a call for service. Someone reported suspicious behavior at a residence. I approached the person, asked questions, and tried to establish what was going on. That's my job."
"Let's begin with the dispatch," Harris said. "What information did you receive before arriving?"
"A caller reported someone outside a house who didn't seem to belong there."
"Did the caller report a crime?"
"I don't recall the exact wording."
"Did the caller report a break-in, an attempted break-in, a threat, or property damage?"
Mitchell shifted in his seat.
"Not specifically, no."
"Did the dispatcher tell you the caller had confirmed the person was a stranger?"
"No."
"Did the dispatcher tell you the caller was uncertain whether the person lived at the address?"
Mitchell looked at Harris.
"I believe that was part of the call."
"It was. The recording indicates the caller said they were not sure whether the person lived there. What did you observe when you arrived?"
"A woman standing on the porch."
"Did you see evidence of a crime?"
"No."
"Did you see forced entry, damaged property, or anyone attempting to enter the residence?"
"No."
"Did you observe a weapon?"
"No."
"Did the woman threaten you?"
"No."
Harris let the answers settle before continuing.
"Then why did you tell her she needed to come down from her porch and identify herself?"
"I was trying to establish who she was."
"Why?"
"Because I needed to determine whether she belonged there."
"Was there a legal requirement for her to prove that she belonged in her own home simply because an anonymous or uncertain caller had questioned her presence?"
Mitchell's face hardened.
"I didn't know at the time that it was her home."
"What facts did you have indicating that she was committing a crime?"
"I didn't say she was committing a crime."
"You described her as suspicious and evasive in your report."
"She was challenging my questions."
"Is challenging an officer's questions the same thing as committing a crime?"
"No."
"Is declining to answer a question always evidence of criminal activity?"
"No."
"Then explain the basis for describing her as suspicious and evasive."
Mitchell opened his notebook, but he did not immediately look at it.
"Her attitude was unusual. She didn't seem interested in cooperating."
"She asked you what the legal basis was for your demand."
"She questioned my authority."
"Which is what the recording shows."
Mitchell's fingers tightened around the edge of his notebook.