But all of them showed why the department needed more than assurances that its procedures were working.
It needed proof.
And somewhere in the restricted archive, behind a file name and a series of unexplained access entries, there might be evidence that would help determine whether Willow Creek had simply made administrative mistakes—or had developed a habit of treating uncomfortable complaints as problems to be closed rather than questions to be answered.
Harris decided that the next person he needed to speak with was the supervisor who had closed the earlier complaint.
The man's name was Peter Lawson. He had retired from the Willow Creek Police Department eight months earlier after nearly thirty years of service. His personnel file contained no major disciplinary actions, and several performance evaluations described him as dependable, experienced, and careful with administrative responsibilities.
Those records made Harris cautious about drawing conclusions. Lawson had built a long career, and it would have been unfair to judge him on an incomplete electronic file. At the same time, his signature appeared beneath a decision that the department could no longer fully explain.
Harris contacted him through the department's official administrative channel and requested a voluntary interview.
Lawson agreed to come in two days later.
When he arrived, he looked older than Harris remembered him. His hair had turned almost completely white, and he moved with the measured pace of someone whose working life no longer required him to hurry through every doorway. He wore a dark jacket and carried a small leather notebook.
"Marcus," Lawson said, offering his hand. "I haven't been in this building in months."
"Thank you for coming, Peter. I know you're retired, and I appreciate your cooperation."
Lawson glanced toward the conference room.
"Is this about the complaints involving Mitchell?"
"One of them, specifically. We're reviewing how the complaint was handled and what evidence was considered."
Lawson's expression became more serious.
"All right."
They sat across from each other. Harris explained that the interview would be documented and that the purpose was to establish what Lawson remembered, not to presume that he had acted improperly.
Then Harris placed a copy of the old complaint summary on the table.
"Do you remember reviewing this case?"
Lawson studied the page.
"The name doesn't immediately bring anything back."
"What about the date?"
Lawson examined it again.
"That was a busy period. We had staffing shortages, several incidents downtown, and a backlog of administrative reviews. I handled a lot of complaints during that time."
"Do you recognize your signature?"
"Yes."
"Do you remember what you reviewed before signing?"
Lawson took a long breath.
"I would normally have reviewed the officer's report, the complainant's statement, and any available recordings."
"Normally?"
"That was the procedure."
"Do you remember whether you watched the body-camera footage in this particular case?"
Lawson stared at the document for several seconds.
"I can't say that I do."
"Do you remember whether the recording was available to you?"
"No."
Harris did not rush to fill the silence.
Lawson rubbed his thumb along the edge of the paper.
"I don't want to tell you I watched something when I can't remember watching it. But I also don't want you to assume I ignored it."
"I'm not making that assumption. That's why we're speaking."
"Good."
"Do you remember the complainant's concern?"
Lawson shook his head.
"Not from this summary."
Harris placed a copy of the handwritten complaint form beside it.
Lawson read the sentence asking the department to examine the recording and determine whether the officer's conduct was permitted.
His face changed slightly.
"That sounds like something a person would write when they believed nobody had listened."
"Do you remember receiving the original form?"
"I don't."
"Do you recognize the handwriting on the closing summary?"
Lawson examined the document.
"The summary was probably prepared by someone in the administrative unit. Supervisors sometimes reviewed the summary and signed the disposition."
"Was that an accepted practice?"
"It happened. I wouldn't say it was the ideal process."
"Was it permitted?"
Lawson hesitated.
"It depended on the circumstances and the rules in place at the time. A supervisor could delegate administrative preparation, but the responsibility for the final decision remained with the supervisor."
"Did signing the summary mean you had personally reviewed the underlying evidence?"
"It should have meant I had reviewed enough information to make the decision."
"Did it always mean that in practice?"
Lawson looked away.
"I would like to tell you it did."
Harris waited.
Lawson finally continued.
"When the department was busy, we sometimes relied too much on summaries. If a report came back with a recommendation that there was no policy violation, and nothing in the summary raised an obvious concern, the supervisor might sign it without reopening every piece of evidence."
"Even if the complaint specifically asked for a recording to be reviewed?"
"If the summary didn't mention that issue, the supervisor might not know the recording was central to the complaint."